Oregon: 4th-Grade Standards

Article Body

(Note: By the completion of fifth grade, Oregon students are expected to master the following standards.)

Benchmark 2 students begin to apply skills to more specific Social Sciences content. Students examine the period of United States History from pre-history through the American Revolution, including focus on the Declaration of Independence. Attention is given to the study of Oregon's tribes. Students study the levels and branches of government at both the state and national levels. In Economics, students continue their study of economic choice to include supply and demand, price, trade, and money. They also study basic concepts of Personal Finance. In geography, students use maps and charts to understand and analyze patterns; compare locations, migration, and population; and to investigate causes of environmental and cultural change. Students extend their work with Social Science Analysis, conducting more sophisticated research, examining primary and secondary sources, establishing cause-and-effect relationships, and drawing conclusions from evidence.

Civics and Government

  • Understand the origins, purposes, and functions of U.S. government, including the structure and meaning of the U.S. Constitution.
    • SS.05.CG.01 Identify essential ideas of our republican form of government as expressed in the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution.
      • SS.05.CG.01.01 Know the concept of "rule of law."
  • Understand the organization, responsibilities, and interrelationships of local, state, and federal governments in the United States.
    • SS.05.CG.02 Identify the primary functions of federal, state, and local governments.
      • SS.05.CG.02.01 Identify public safety, transportation, education, and recreation as responsibilities of local governments.
      • SS.05.CG.02.02 Know how laws are made.
  • Understand the roles of the three branches of government and explain how their powers are distributed and shared.
    • SS.05.CG.03 Understand the roles and responsibilities of the three branches of government.
      • SS.05.CG.03.01 Name and distinguish the primary function of each branch of government at the federal and state levels.
  • Understand personal and political rights of citizens in the United States.
    • SS.05.CG.04 Identify the rights of U.S. citizens.
      • SS.05.CG.04.01 Identify basic rights that are given to citizens of the United States.
  • Understand participatory responsibilities of citizens in the community (voluntarism) and in the political process (becoming informed about public issues and candidates, joining political parties/interest groups/associations, communicating with public officials, voting, influencing lawmaking through such processes as petitions/initiatives).
    • SS.05.CG.05 Understand how citizens can learn about public issues.
      • SS.05.CG.05.01 Identify and give examples of resources that provide information about public issues.
  • Understand how government is influenced and changed by support and dissent of individuals, groups, and international organizations.
    • SS.05.CG.06 Identify and give examples of how individuals can influence the actions of government.
      • SS.05.CG.06.01 Identify and give examples of actions citizens can take to influence government policy and decision-making.
  • Understand how nations interact with each other, how events and issues in other countries can affect citizens in the United States, and how actions and concepts of democracy and individual rights of the United States can affect other peoples and nations.
    • SS.05.CG.07 Recognize and give examples of how nations interact with one another through trade, diplomacy, cultural contacts, treaties, and agreements.
      • SS.05.CG.07.01 Know how the United States makes treaties with other nations, including Indian nations.
      • SS.05.CG.07.02 Know how nations demonstrate good will toward other nations in a variety of ways.
  • Analyze major political systems of the world.
    • SS.05.CG.08 Understand that there are different ways for governments to be organized.
      • SS.05.CG.08.01 Recognize that governments are organized in different ways.

Economics

  • Understand that resources are limited (e.g., scarcity).
    • SS.05.EC.01 Understand that all economic choices have costs and benefits, and compare options in terms of costs and benefits.
      • SS.05.EC.01.01 Know that whenever a choice is made, there is a cost.
  • Understand economic trade-offs and how choices result in both costs and benefits to individuals and society.
    • SS.05.EC.02 Identify and give examples of the concepts of "trade-off" and "opportunity costs."
      • SS.05.EC.02.01 Identify and give examples of consequences of economic choices in terms of trade- off and opportunity cost.
      • SS.05.EC.02.02 Understand the difference between "needs" and "wants" and their relationship to economic trade-offs.
  • Understand how conditions in an economy influence and are influenced by the decisions of consumers, producers, economic institutions, and government.
    • SS.05.EC.03 Understand how supply and demand influence price, and how price increases or decreases influence the decisions of consumers.
      • SS.05.EC.03.01 Understand that prices rise and fall depending on supply and demand.
  • Understand the interdependence of the global economy and the role played by the United States.
    • SS.05.EC.04 Recognize examples of how nations interact economically.
      • SS.05.EC.04.01 Recognize that nations interact through trade.
  • Understand how money makes it easier to trade, borrow, save, invest, and compare the value of goods and services.
    • SS.05.EC.05 Identify the characteristics of money and the advantages of its use over barter.
      • SS.05.EC.05.01 Distinguish between "barter" and "money" and how they facilitate the exchange of goods.
  • Apply economic concepts and principles to issues of personal finance.
    • SS.05.EC.06 Understand the processes of earning, saving, spending, budgeting, and record keeping in money management.
      • SS.05.EC.06.01 Recognize that people earn income by exchanging their labor for wages and salaries.
      • SS.05.EC.06.02 Recognize that savings are the part of income not spent on taxes or consumption.
      • SS.05.EC.06.03 Recognize that spending involves exchanging money for goods or services.
      • SS.05.EC.06.04 Recognize that a budget is a record-keeping plan for managing income and spending.
    • SS.05.EC.07 Understand how banks and credit unions serve savers and borrowers.
      • SS.05.EC.07.01 Understand how interest creates incentives for borrowing and saving.

Geography

  • Understand the spatial concepts of location, distance, direction, scale, movement, and region.
    • SS.05.GE.01 Define basic geography vocabulary such as concepts of location, direction, distance, scale, movement, and region using appropriate words and diagrams.
      • SS.05.GE.01.01 Know and use basic map elements to answer geographic questions or display geographic information.
  • Use maps and other geographic tools and technologies to acquire, process, and report information from a spatial perspective.
    • SS.05.GE.02 Examine and understand how to prepare maps, charts, and other visual representations to locate places and interpret geographic information.
      • SS.05.GE.02.01 Use maps and charts to interpret geographic information.
      • SS.05.GE.02.02 Use other visual representations to locate, identify, and distinguish physical and human features of places and regions.
  • Locate major physical and human (cultural) features of the Earth.
    • SS.05.GE.03 Locate and identify on maps the continents of the world, the 50 states of the United States, and the major physical features of Oregon.
      • SS.05.GE.03.01 Identify the names of the continents and their relative size, shape, and location.
      • SS.05.GE.03.02 Identify the names of the fifty states and their location relative to other states.
      • SS.05.GE.03.03 Locate, identify, and know the significance of major mountains, rivers, and land regions of Oregon.
  • Compare and analyze physical (e.g., landforms, vegetation, wildlife, climate, and natural hazards) and human (e.g., population, land use, language, and religion) characteristics of places and regions.
    • SS.05.GE.04 Identify physical and human characteristics of regions in the United States and the processes that have shaped them.
      • SS.05.GE.04.01 Identify and locate major landforms, bodies of water, vegetation, and climate found in regions of the United States.
      • SS.05.GE.04.02 Identify the type of economic activity, population distribution, and cities found in regions of the United States.
  • Analyze the causes of human migration (e.g., density, food and water supply, transportation and communication systems) and it effects (e.g., impact on physical and human systems).
    • SS.05.GE.05 Identify patterns of migration and cultural interaction in the United States.
      • SS.05.GE.05.01 Understand how physical geography affects the routes, flow, and destinations of migration.
      • SS.05.GE.05.02 Explain how migrations affect the culture of emigrants and native populations.
  • Understand economic, cultural, and environmental factors that influence changes in population, and evaluate the consequences of the resulting increases or decreases in population.
    • SS.05.GE.06 Identify and give examples of issues related to population increases and decreases.
      • SS.05.GE.06.01 Identify and give examples of positive and negative impacts of population increases or decreases.
  • Understand how people and the environment are interrelated.
    • SS.05.GE.07 Understand how physical environments are affected by human activities.
      • SS.05.GE.07.01 Understand how and why people alter the physical environment.
      • SS.05.GE.07.02 Describe how human activity can impact the environment.
    • SS.05.GE.08 Understand how human activities are affected by the physical environment.
      • SS.05.GE.08.01 Identify constraints on human activity caused by the physical environment.
      • SS.05.GE.08.02 Understand how the physical environment presents opportunities for economic and recreational activity.

History

  • Historical Skills: Interpret and reconstruct chronological relationships.
    • SS.05.HS.01 Interpret data and chronological relationships presented in timelines and narratives.
      • SS.05.HS.01.01 Order events found in historical narratives.
      • SS.05.HS.01.02 Calculate time and infer information from timelines.
  • Historical Skills: Analyze cause and effect relationships, including multiple causalities.
    • SS.05.HS.02 Identify cause and effect relationships in a sequence of events.
  • Historical Skills: Understand, recognize, and interpret change and continuity over time.
    • SS.05.HS.03 Understand how history can be organized using themes, geography, or chronology.
  • Historical Skills: Identify and analyze diverse perspectives on and historical interpretation of historical issues and events.
    • SS.05.HS.04 Identify primary and secondary sources.
  • U.S. History: Understand and interpret events, issues, and developments within and across eras of U.S. history.
    • SS.05.HS.05 Understand how individuals, issues, and events changed or significantly influenced the course of U.S. history from pre-history through the period of the American Revolution.
      • SS.05.HS.05.01 Identify and understand the groups living in the Western Hemisphere before European exploration, their ways of life, and the empires they developed.
      • SS.05.HS.05.02 Understand the impact of early European exploration on Native Americans and on the land.
      • SS.05.HS.05.03 Understand the impact of individuals through the period of the American Revolution, on ideas, ways of life, or the course of events in U.S. history.
      • SS.05.HS.05.04 Understand the colonial experience and how it led to the American Revolution.
      • SS.05.HS.05.05 Identify and understand the causes, course, and impact of the American Revolution, including the roles of George Washington, Samuel Adams, and Thomas Jefferson.
  • State & Local History: Understand and interpret the history of the state of Oregon.
    • SS.05.HS.06 Understand how individuals changed or significantly influenced the course of Oregon state history.
      • SS.05.HS.06.01 Identify significant people in the history of Oregon from pre-history through the period of the American Revolution.
      • SS.05.HS.06.02 Understand the interactions and contributions of the various people and cultures that have lived in or migrated to the area that is now Oregon from pre-history through the period of the American Revolution.
  • State & Local History: Understand and interpret events, issues, and developments in the history of one’s family, local community, and culture.
    • SS.05.HS.07 Understand how individuals changed or significantly influenced the course of local history.

Social Science Analysis

  • Define and clarify an issue so that its dimensions are well understood.
    • SS.05.SA.01 Examine an event, issue, or problem through inquiry and research.
  • Acquire and organize materials from primary and secondary sources.
    • SS.05.SA.02 Gather, use, and document information from multiple sources (e.g. print, electronic, human, primary, secondary).
  • Explain various perspectives on an event or issue and the reasoning behind them.
    • SS.05.SA.03 Identify and study two or more points of view of an event, issue, or problem.
  • Identify and analyze an issue.
    • SS.05.SA.04 Identify characteristics of an event, issue, or problem, suggesting possible causes and results.
  • Select a course of action to resolve an issue.
    • SS.05.SA.05 Identify a response or solution and support why it makes sense, using support from research.

New Mexico: 4th-Grade Standards

Article Body
  • Strand: History

    Content Standard I: Students are able to identify important people and events in order to analyze significant patterns, relationships, themes, ideas, beliefs, and turning points in New Mexico, United States, and world history in order to understand the complexity of the human experience.

    • Grade 4 Benchmark I-A—New Mexico:

      Describe how contemporary and historical people and events have influenced New Mexico communities and regions.

      Performance Standards

      1. Identify important issues, events, and individuals from New Mexico pre-history to the present.
      2. Describe the role of contemporary figures and how their contributions and perspectives are creating impact in New Mexico.
    • Grade 4 Benchmark I-B—United States:

      Understand connections among historical events, people, and symbols significant to United States history and cultures.

      Performance Standards

      1. Describe local events and their connections and relationships to national history.
    • Grade 4 Benchmark I-C—World:

      Students will identify and describe similar historical characteristics of the United States and its neighboring countries.

      Performance Standards

      1. Explain how historical events, people, and culture influence present day Canada, Mexico, and the United States (e.g., food, art, shelter, language).
    • Grade 4 Benchmark I-D—Skills:

      Understand time passage and chronology.

      Performance Standards

      1. Describe and explain how historians and archaeologists provide information about people in different time periods.
  • Strand: Geography

    Content Standard II: Students understand how physical, natural, and cultural processes influence where people live, the ways in which people live, and how societies interact with one another and their environments.

    • Grade 4 Benchmark II-A:

      Understand the concept of location by using and constructing maps, globes, and other geographic tools to identify and derive information about people, places, and environments.

      Performance Standards

      1. Apply geographic tools of title, grid system, legends, symbols, scale and compass rose to construct and interpret maps.
      2. Translate geographic information into a variety of formats such as graphs, maps, diagrams and charts.
      3. Draw conclusions and make generalizations from geographic information and inquiry.
    • Grade 4 Benchmark II-B:

      Distinguish between natural and human characteristics of places and use this knowledge to define regions, their relationships with other regions, and patterns of change.

      Performance Standards

      1. Identify a region as an area with unifying characteristics (e.g., human, weather, agriculture, industry, natural characteristics).
      2. Describe the regions of New Mexico, the United States, and the Western Hemisphere.
      3. Identify ways in which different individuals and groups of people view and relate to places and regions.
    • Grade 4 Benchmark II-C:

      Be familiar with aspects of human behavior and man-made and natural environments in order to recognize their impact on the past and present.

      Performance Standards

      1. Explain how geographic factors have influenced people, including settlement patterns and population distribution in New Mexico, past and present.
      2. Describe how environments, both natural and man-made, have influenced people and events over time, and describe how places change.
      3. Understand how visual data (e.g., maps, graphs, diagrams, tables, charts) organizes and presents geographic information.
    • Grade 4 Benchmark II-D:

      Understand how physical processes shape the Earth's surface patterns and biosystems.

      Performance Standards

      1. Explain how the Earth-Sun relationships produce day and night, seasons, major climatic variations, and cause the need for time zones.
      2. Describe the four provinces (plains, mountains, plateau, and basin and range) that make up New Mexicoís land surface (geographic conditions).
    • Grade 4 Benchmark II-E:

      Describe how economic, political, cultural, and social processes interact to shape patterns of human populations, and their interdependence, cooperation, and conflict.

      Performance Standards

      1. Describe how cultures change.
      2. Describe how geographic factors influence the location and distribution of economic activities.
      3. Describe types and patterns of settlements.
      4. Identify the causes of human migration.
      5. Describe how and why people create boundaries and describe types of boundaries.
    • Grade 4 Benchmark II-F:

      Describe how natural and man-made changes affect the meaning, use, distribution, and value of resources.

      Performance Standards

      1. Identify the distributions of natural and man-made resources in New Mexico, the Southwest, and the United States.
  • Strand: Civics and Government

    Content Standard III: Students understand the ideals, rights, and responsibilities of citizenship and understand the content and history of the founding documents of the United States with particular emphasis on the United States and New Mexico constitutions and how governments function at local, state, tribal, and national levels.

    • Grade 4 Benchmark III-A:

      Know the fundamental purposes, concepts, structures, and functions of local, state, tribal, and national governments.

      Performance Standards

      1. Explain how the organization of New Mexicoís government changed during its early history.
      2. Compare how the State of New Mexico serves national interests and the interests of New Mexicans.
      3. Explain the difference between making laws, carrying out the laws, and determining if the laws have been broken, and identify the government bodies that perform these functions at the local, state, tribal, and national levels.
    • Grade 4 Benchmark III-B:

      Identify and describe the symbols, icons, songs, traditions, and leaders of local, state, tribal, and national levels that exemplify ideals and provide continuity and a sense of community across time.

      Performance Standards

      1. Describe various cultures and the communities they represent, and explain how they have evolved over time.
    • Grade 4 Benchmark III-C:

      Become familiar with the basic purposes of government in New Mexico and the United States.

      Performance Standards

      1. Compare and contrast how the various governments have applied rules/laws, majority rule, ìpublic good,î and protections of the minority in different periods of New Mexicoís history.
    • Grade 4 Benchmark III- D:

      Understand rights and responsibilities of "good citizenship" as members of a family, school and community.

      Performance Standards

      1. Explain the difference between rights and responsibilities, why we have rules and laws, and the role of citizenship in promoting them.
      2. Examine issues of human rights.
  • Strand: Economics

    Content Standard IV: Students understand basic economic principles and use economic reasoning skills to analyze the impact of economic systems (including the market economy) on individuals, families, businesses, communities, and governments.

    • Grade 4 Benchmark IV-A:

      Understand that individuals, households, businesses, governments, and societies make decisions that affect the distribution of resources and that these decisions are influenced by incentives (both economic and intrinsic).

      Performance Standards

      1. Understand when choices are made that those choices impose ìopportunity costs.î
      2. Describe different economic, public, and/or community incentives (wages, business profits, amenities rights for property owners and renters).
      3. Illustrate how resources can be used in alternative ways and, sometimes, allocated to different users.
      4. Explain why there may be unequal distribution of resources (e.g., among people, communities, states, nations).
      5. Understand and explain how conflict may arise between private and public incentives (e.g., new parks, parking structures).
    • Grade 4 Benchmark IV-B:

      Understand that economic systems impact the way individuals, households, businesses, governments, and societies make decisions about goods and services.

      Performance Standards

      1. Understand how the characteristics and benefits of the free enterprise system in New Mexico compares to other economic systems in New Mexico (e.g., acequia sytems).
      2. Explain that government raises money by taxing and borrowing to pay for the goods and services it provides.
    • Grade 4 Benchmark IV-C:

      Understand the patterns and results of trade and exchange among individuals, households, businesses, governments, and societies, and their interdependent qualities.

      Performance Standards

      1. Identify patterns of work and economic activity in New Mexico and their sustainability over time (e.g., farming, ranching, mining, retail, transportation, manufacturing, tourism, high tech).
      2. Explain how New Mexico, the United States, and other parts of the world are economically interdependent.
      3. Explain that banks handle currency and other forms of money and serve as intermediaries between savers and borrowers.
      4. Explain that money can be used to express the ìmarket valueî of goods and services in the form of prices.
      5. Use data to explain an economic pattern.

Utah: 4th-Grade Standards

Article Body

In the fourth grade, students will build on these foundational concepts as they learn about the present state of Utah. Students will study history, government, economics, culture, and geography to build their understanding of Utah's past and present, as well as make inferences about Utah's future. Inquiry into current events will help students make connections between the past and the present. Students will enlarge their world connections as they trace the global travels of people from many diverse cultures who now call Utah home.

The most important goal: a well-lived life

Excitement, wonder, inquiry, delight, and puzzlement are central to meaningful learning in social studies. Social studies should be fun and intriguing for all students, and provide opportunities to make important life-long connections between the past, present, and future. Students who appreciate the sacrifices that have been made in the past and understand the challenges that lie ahead can make better decisions in the present.

Core Standards of the Course

Benchmark: Utah's physical geography has a direct impact on the cultures of the various peoples who have inhabited it throughout time. By learning about the physical geography of Utah and how it has changed over time, students will be able to understand the interrelationships between the physical geography of Utah and human cultural development.

  • Standard 1

    Students will understand the relationship between the physical geography in Utah and human life.

    • Objective 1

      Classify major physical geographic attributes of Utah.

      • a. Identify Utah's latitude, longitude, hemisphere, climate, natural resources, landforms, and regions using a variety of geographic tools.
      • b. Examine the forces at work in creating the physical geography of Utah (e.g. erosion, seismic activity, climate change).
    • Objective 2

      Analyze how physical geography affects human life in Utah.

      • a. Identify population concentrations in the state and infer causal relationships between population and physical geography.
      • b. Classify the distribution and use of natural resources.
      • c. Compare the development of industry and business in Utah as it relates to its physical geography (e.g. mining, oil, agriculture, tourism).
      • d. Make inferences about the relationships between the physical geography of Utah and the state's communication and transportation systems (e.g. trails, roads, telegraph, rail lines).
      • e. Examine the interactions between physical geography and public health and safety (e.g. inversions, earthquakes, flooding, fire).
      • f. Explain how archaeology informs about the past (e.g. artifacts, ruins, excavations).
    • Objective 3

      Analyze how human actions modify the physical environment.

      • a. Describe how and why humans have changed the physical environment of Utah to meet their needs (e.g. reservoirs, irrigation, climate, transportation systems and cities).
      • b. Explain viewpoints regarding environmental issues (e.g. species protection, land use, pollution controls, mass transit, water rights, trust lands).
      • c. Outline the development of recreation in Utah since 1900 (e.g. sports, tourism, state, and national parks).
      • d. Make data-supported predictions about the future needs of Utahns and the natural resources that will be necessary to meet those needs.

    Social Studies Vocabulary Students Should Know and Use: natural resources, landforms, regions, erosion, seismic activity, tourism, communication, transportation, archaeology, artifacts, excavations

  • Benchmark: The history of Utah has been shaped by many diverse people, events, challenges, and ideas. People came to the land now known as Utah for many reasons, and from many different places around the world. The story of Utah includes American Indians, the Dominguez- Escalante exploration, explorers, trappers, Latinos, Mormon pioneers, Polynesians, Chinese, Japanese, Greeks, African-Americans, Middle Easterners, and many other groups seeking new homes, work and refuge. As each culture has come to Utah, Utah has changed. These changes have had and will continue to have significant impacts on all the people of Utah.

  • Standard 2

    Students will understand how Utah's history has been shaped by many diverse people, events, and ideas.

    • Objective 1

      Describe the historical and current impact of various cultural groups on Utah.

      • a. Chart the routes that diverse cultural groups took from their places of origin to Utah, using maps and other resources.
      • b. Explore points of view about life in Utah from a variety of cultural groups using primary source documents.
      • c. Explore cultural influences from various groups found in Utah today (e.g. food, music, religion, dress, festivals).
      • d. Identify and describe leaders from various cultures who exemplify outstanding character and life skills.
      • e. Explain the importance of preserving cultural prehistory and history, including archaeological sites and other historic sites and artifacts.
    • Objective 2

      Describe ways that Utah has changed over time.

      • a. Identify key events and trends in Utah history and their significance (e.g. American Indian settlement, European exploration, Mormon settlement, westward expansion, American Indian relocation, statehood, development of industry, World War I and II).
      • b. Compare the experiences faced by today's immigrants with those faced by immigrants in Utah's history.
    • Objective 3

      Investigate the development of the economy in Utah.

      • a. Explain the relationship between supply and demand.
      • b. Describe the role of producers and consumers.
      • c. Identify examples of producers and consumers in the local community.
      • d. Research the development of Utah's economy over time.
      • e. Identify the factors which bring about economic changes (e.g. natural resource development, new technologies, new market development, globalization, global conflicts, education).
      • f. Examine how economic development affects communities (e.g. dams, sports, tourism, power plants, mining, etc.).

    Social Studies Vocabulary Students Should Know and Use: immigrant, supply, demand, producer, economy, consumer, technology, globalization

  • Benchmark: Representative government has developed in Utah. People who live in Utah have rights and responsibilities associated with representative government. People have created systems of power and authority within this government.

  • Standard 3

    Students will understand the roles of civic life, politics, and government in the lives of Utah citizens.

    • Objective 1

      Describe the responsibilities and rights of individuals in a representative government as well as in the school and community.

      • a. Identify rights of a citizen (e.g. voting, peaceful assembly, freedom of religion).
      • b. Identify responsibilities of a citizen (e.g. jury duty, obeying the law, paying taxes).
      • c. Determine how and why the rights and responsibilities of various groups have varied over time (e.g. Chinese railroad workers, Greek miners, women, children, Mormons, Japanese-Americans at Topaz, American Indians, African-Americans).
      • d. how the influence and power of individuals is affected when they organize into groups.
      • e. Describe and model ways that citizens can participate in civic responsibilities (e.g. current issue analysis, recycling, volunteering with civic organizations, letter writing).
      • f. Contribute to and practice classroom goals, rules and responsibilities.
      • g. Recognize and demonstrate respect for United States and Utah symbols (i.e. Pledge of Allegiance, flag etiquette).
    • Objective 2

      Analyze the different ways people have organized governments in Utah to meet community needs.

      • a. Identify the forms of government found in Utah in different eras (i.e. historic and current American Indian government, State of Deseret, Utah Territory, statehoodera, present).
      • b. Compare how these governments addressed community needs.
      • c. Compare the roles and responsibilities of state, county, and local officials.

    Social Studies Vocabulary Students Should Know and Use: citizen, civic organizations, allegiance, representative, rights, responsibilities, government

Alabama: 4th-Grade Standards

Article Body

AL.4. Standard: Alabama Studies

Fourth-grade students apply geographic concepts obtained in Grade 3 to a study of their own state and relate geography to history, economics, and politics in Alabama. They examine ways economic and political institutions respond to the needs of Alabamians.

4.1

  • 4.1.1 Students will:

    Compare historical and current economic, political, and geographic information about Alabama on thematic maps, including weather and climate, physical-relief, waterway, transportation, political, economic development, land-use, and population maps (Economics, Geography, History, Civics and Government).

  • 4.1.2 Students will practice:

    Describing types of migrations as they affect the environment, agriculture, economic development, and population changes in Alabama

4.2

  • 4.2.1 Students will:

    Relate reasons for European exploration and settlement in Alabama to the impact of European explorers on trade, health, and land expansion in Alabama (Economics, Geography, History, Civics and Government).

  • 4.2.2 Students will practice:

    • Locating on maps European settlements in early Alabama, including Fort Condé, Fort Toulouse, and Fort Mims
    • Tracing, on maps and globes, routes of early explorers of the New World, including Juan Ponce de León, Hernando de Soto, and Vasco Núñez de Balboa
    • Explaining reasons for conflicts between Europeans and American Indians in Alabama from 1519 to 1840, including differing beliefs regarding land ownership, religion, and culture

4.3

  • 4.3.1 Students will:

    Explain the social, political, and economic impact of the War of 1812, including battles and significant leaders of the Creek War, on Alabama (Economics, Geography, History, Civics and Government).

    • Grade Level Example:

      social—adoption of European culture by American Indians, opening of Alabama land for settlement
      political—forced relocation of American Indians, labeling of Andrew Jackson as a hero and propelling him toward Presidency
      economic—acquisition of tribal land in Alabama by the United States

  • 4.3.2 Students will practice:

    Explaining the impact of the Trail of Tears on Alabama American Indians’ lives, rights, and territories

4.4

  • 4.4.1 Students will:

    Relate the relationship of the five geographic regions of Alabama to the movement of Alabama settlers during the early nineteenth century (Geography, History).

  • 4.4.2 Students will practice:

    • Recognizing natural resources of Alabama during the early nineteenth century
    • Describing human environments of Alabama as they relate to settlement during the early nineteenth century, including housing, roads, and place names

4.5

  • 4.5.1 Students will:

    Describe Alabama’s entry into statehood and establishment of its three branches of government and the constitutions. (Geography, History, Civics and Government).

  • 4.5.2 Students will practice:

    • Explaining political and geographic reasons for changes in location of Alabama’s state capital
    • Recognizing roles of prominent political leaders during early statehood in Alabama, including William Wyatt Bibb, Thomas Bibb, Israel Pickens, William Rufus King, and John W. Walker

4.6

  • 4.6.1 Students will:

    Describe cultural, economic, and political aspects of the lifestyles of early nineteenth-century farmers, plantation owners, slaves, and townspeople (Economics, Geography, History, Civics and Government).

    • Grade Level Example:

      cultural—housing, education, religion, recreation
      economic—transportation, means of support
      political—inequity of legal codes

  • 4.6.2 Students will practice:

    Describing major areas of agricultural production in Alabama, including the Black Belt and fertile river valleys

4.7

  • 4.7.1 Students will:

    Explain reasons for Alabama’s secession from the Union, including sectionalism, slavery, states’ rights, and economic disagreements (Economics, History, Civics and Government).

  • 4.7.2 Students will practice:

    • Identifying Alabama’s role in the organization of the Confederacy, including hosting the secession convention and the inauguration ceremony for leaders
    • Recognizing Montgomery as the first capital of the Confederacy
    • Interpreting the Articles of the Confederation and the Gettysburg Address

4.8

  • 4.8.1 Students will:

    Explain Alabama’s economic and military role during the Civil War (Economics, History).

    • Grade Level Example:

      economic—production of iron products, munitions, textiles, and ships
      military—provision of military supplies through the Port of Mobile, provision of armament center at Selma

  • 4.8.2 Students will practice:

    • Recognizing military leaders from Alabama during the Civil War
    • Comparing roles of women during and after the Civil War on the home front and battlefront
    • Explaining economic conditions as a result of the Civil War, including the collapse of the economic structure, destruction of the transportation infrastructure, and high casualty rates

4.9

  • 4.9.1 Students will:

    Analyze political and economic issues facing Alabama during Reconstruction for their impact on various social groups (Economics, History, Civics and Government).

    • Grade Level Example:

      political issues—military rule, presence of Freedmen’s Bureau, Alabama’s readmittance to the Union
      economic issues—sharecropping, tenant farming, scarcity of goods and money

  • 4.9.2 Students will practice:

    • Interpreting the Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments to the Constitution of the United States
    • Identifying African Americans who had an impact on Alabama during Reconstruction in Alabama
    • Identifying major political parties in Alabama during Reconstruction

4.10

  • 4.10.1 Students will:

    Analyze social and educational changes during the late nineteenth and early twentieth century for their impact on Alabama (Economics, History, Civics and Government).

    • Grade Level Example:

      social—implementation of the Plessy versus Ferguson ―separate but equal‖ court decision, birth of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP)
      educational—establishment of normal schools and land-grant colleges such as Alabama Agricultural and Mechanical (A&M) University, Auburn University, Tuskegee University, Alabama State University

  • 4.10.2 Students will practice:

    • Explaining the development and changing role of industry, trade, and agriculture in Alabama during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, including the rise of Populism
    • Explaining Jim Crow laws
    • Identifying Alabamians who made contributions in the fields of science, education, the arts, politics, and business during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries

4.11

  • 4.11.1 Students will:

    Describe the impact of World War I on Alabamians, including the migration of African Americans from Alabama to the North and West, utilization of Alabama’s military installations and training facilities, and increased production of goods for the war effort (Geography, History).

  • 4.11.2 Students will practice:

      • Recognizing Alabama participants in World War I, including Alabama’s 167th Regiment of the Rainbow Division
      • Identifying World War I technologies, including airplanes, machine guns, and chemical warfare
  • 4.12

    • 4.12.1 Students will:

      Explain the impact the 1920s and Great Depression had on different socioeconomic groups in Alabama (Economics, History).

      • Grade Level Example:

        Impact of the 1920s—increase in availability of electricity, employment opportunities, wages, products, consumption of goods and services; overproduction of goods; stock market crash
        Impact of the Great Depression—overcropping of land, unemployment, poverty, establishment of new federal programs

    • 4.12.2 Students will practice:

      Explaining how supply and demand impacted economies of Alabama and the United States during the 1920s and the Great Depression

    4.13

    • 4.13.1 Students will:

      Describe the economic and social impact of World War II on Alabamians, including the entry of women into the workforce, increase in job opportunities, rationing, utilization of Alabama’s military installations, military recruitment, the draft, and a rise in racial consciousness (Economics, Geography, History).

    • 4.13.2 Students will practice:

      • Recognizing Alabama participants in World War II, including the Tuskegee Airmen and women in the military
      • Justifying the strategic placement of military bases in Alabama, including Redstone Arsenal, Fort Rucker, Fort McClellan, and Craig Air Force Base

    4.14

    • 4.14.1 Students will:

      Analyze the modern Civil Rights Movement to determine the social, political, and economic impact on Alabama (Economics, History, Civics and Government).

    • 4.14.2 Students will practice:

      • Recognizing important persons of the modern Civil Rights Movement, including Martin Luther King, Jr., George C. Wallace, Rosa Parks, Fred Shuttlesworth, John Lewis, Malcolm X, Thurgood Marshall, Hugo Black, and Ralph David Abernathy
      • Describing events of the modern Civil Rights Movement, including the Montgomery Bus Boycott, the Sixteenth Street Baptist Church bombing in Birmingham, the Freedom Riders bus bombing, and the Selma-to-Montgomery March
      • Explaining benefits of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Voting Rights Act of 1965, and Brown versus Board of Education Supreme Court case of 1954
      • Using vocabulary associated with the modern Civil Rights Movement, including discrimination, prejudice, segregation, integration, suffrage, and rights

    4.15

    • 4.15. Students will:

      Identify major world events that influenced Alabama since 1950, including the Korean Conflict, the Cold War, the Vietnam War, the Persian Gulf War, and the War on Terrorism. (History).

    4.16

    • 4.16.1 Students will:

      Determine the impact of population growth on cities, major road systems, demographics, natural resources, and the natural environment of Alabama during the late twentieth century and early twenty-first century (Economics, Geography, History).

    • 4.16.2 Students will practice:

      • Describing how technological advancements brought change to Alabamians, including the telephone; refrigerator; automobile; television; and wireless, Internet, and space technologies
      • Relating Alabama’s economy to the influence of foreign-based industry, including the automobile industry

    Confronting the "Official Story" of American History

    Image
    "Washington Crossing the Deleware". Emanuel Gottlieb Leutze. 1851 oil on canvas
    Article Body

    Keith Barton of Indiana University and Linda Levstik of the University of Kentucky wanted to understand the "official" story of American history so often presented in classrooms and textbooks. What happens to aspects of history that don’t fit the way we usually teach U.S. history? And how do students respond?

    Barton and Levstik interviewed 48 children, grades 5–8, to see how middle-schoolers understand the significance of particular events. Students were asked to choose from a number of historical events in order to determine which eight to include on a timeline of the last 500 years.

    Many students alighted on a central theme in U.S. history: steadily expanding rights and opportunities. While stories like this help structure students' thinking about American history, traditional themes (such as perpetual progress or expanding freedoms) left them ill-equipped to deal with issues like racial inequality or political dissent.

    While stories . . . help structure students' thinking about American history, traditional themes . . . left them ill-equipped to deal with issues like racial inequality or political dissent.

    This study suggests that middle-grade students may need help grasping the complexities of the past or finding a place for stories that don’t fit common narratives. The authors proposed that teachers expose students to more complex and diverse perspectives by identifying what such narratives leave out. How has progress not been achieved? Where have freedoms not been expanded? What are the exceptions, the outliers, the cases that don’t fit? The researchers believe that students can learn traditional thematic narratives, while at the same time exploring the richness and complexity of history.

    Thematic Trends

    When Barton and Levstik interviewed the students, they found a core group of themes emerged from the events students chose as the most significant. Stories of national origin, American exceptionality, expanding freedoms, and technological progress consistently appeared among the students' choices. Such themes represented an "official version" of American history that all students seemed to recognize.

    Alternative Stories

    Some students viewed events as important despite the fact that their themes did not easily fit into the more popular narratives. Racism and sexism directly contradict themes of progress and expanding freedoms. Other events like the Great Depression and the Vietnam War fly in the face of American exceptionality. In both cases, however, students found it challenging to explain why they found these events significant. While students were convinced of the importance of such events, they struggled to reconcile them with common themes of U.S. history.

    Two Ideas in Their Minds

    American history presents a wide variety of events and themes. Some, like our nation’s heritage regarding race, class, and gender, pose particular challenges. Accustomed to justifying the importance of events by referencing a few common themes, many students find themselves at a loss when confronted by events they know are important, but which don’t seem to fit the stories they are used to hearing. Lacking an overarching framework to help make sense of such events, they develop overly simplistic explanations to reconcile jarring events with the official story. As the sample application below shows, their explanations may put events together, but at the expense of historical accuracy.

    image
    Photomechanical print, Progress, Keppler & Schwarzmann, c. 1901, LoC
    In the Classroom
    • Have students create a timeline of important events in American history, asking them to explain why they make particular choices.
    • After students create their timeline, discuss the major themes that arise from their picks. Do they seem to represent an "official" history?
    • Once they have identified common historical themes, ask students to pick out events that don’t fit the "official story." What might explain this lack of fit?
    Sample Application

    When learning about the Great Depression, one group of students demonstrated a characteristic dilemma. As far as they knew, throughout its history the United States had been on a steady march of economic progress. Consequently, students weren't sure how the Great Depression fit into this story:

    • "It wasn't a good part of history."
    • "It was something to learn from."
    • "It was the first time our country had become really poor."
    • "They realized that they weren’t the god of all countries."
    • "It’s not going to be perfect all the time."

    As these quotes demonstrate, students had accumulated a wide range of conceptions about the Great Depression. They knew bad things had happened, but thought these occurred uniformly to all Americans. As a result, they concluded that the nation had been punished for being too prosperous or self-satisfied. They entirely missed the fact that the Great Depression occurred for many specific and complex reasons, and affected different Americans in dramatically diverse ways.

    Bibliography

    Keith C. Barton and Linda S. Levstik, "'It Wasn’t a Good Part of History': National Identity and Students' Explanations of Historical Significance," Teachers College Record 99, no. 3 (Spring 1998): 478–513.

    Amy Trenkle's Be the Blogger!

    Date Published
    Image
    Blog, Lincoln Logs, http://stampslincoln.blogspot.com/, Amy Trenkle
    Blog, Lincoln Logs, http://stampslincoln.blogspot.com/, Amy Trenkle
    Article Body
    Beginning to Blog

    During the 2008–2009 school year, in an effort to integrate more technology into my classroom I started blogging with my students about history class. Because I was pretty new to blogging and wasn’t sure how it would go, I did one collective site for the 8th grade. Basically, the students wrote and I uploaded it to the blog. As the year went on, I logged in for students and they took over the maintenance of the site. Sometimes the writing was an assignment and I chose the best ones to post. Other times, I offered extra credit if they posted about a topic provided. And still other times I loved what a student wrote and typed it up for the blog. This site ended up being a wonderful compilation of our year come June. I still use it as a preview site for students, parents, and pre-service teachers I work with, as to what we do during the year. The blog can be viewed at http://shmshistoryclass.blogspot.com/.

    That same year, an after-school group that is co-sponsored by myself and a friend from the National Park Service took a cross-country trip for Lincoln’s Bicentennial. I created another blog for the students to document their adventures and for friends and family back home to be able to find us. What was nice was that because I had been working with the blog in history class, my students were aware of how a blog works and were familiar with how to write for it and their audience. Each student was required to write three times for the blog during the course of our week-long adventure. Each night after our full day they would write on either paper or share the two laptops we brought for blogging. Before going to bed each night I would upload any remaining blog entries. The system proved effective for sharing our adventures and for students documenting their days. The site has also become a great way for Jen Epstein, my National Park Service co-organizer, to share what she is doing in schools for outreach. View it here: http://stampslincoln.blogspot.com/.

    Blogging Expanded

    With two school group blogs under my belt, I decided to ramp it up for the 2009–2010 school year. I wanted students to be able to learn how to blog . . . not just post, but learn the process. I set out the planning of it before school started. Basically, I decided to have students choose their groupmates in the class they were in. I have approximately 100 students each year and about 25 per history class. I asked them to be in groups of three or four students.

    I wanted students to be able to learn how to blog . . . not just post, but learn the process.

    Once they chose their groups (and we discussed the characteristics of a quality groupmate, both in a group partner and as a group partner—they are 8th grade after all!), I gave them a sheet that asked them to record their group member names, create a name for their blog, and to write a username and a password that they would remember (not one that was already in use by one of the group members!). I created Google accounts for each student using the information provided, noting on their sheet, if a username was taken, the reassigned username.

    Generally, I’ve found that it takes about a week for me to set up the 30 or so email accounts and blog sites. I introduce the blog and what it will be about, how it will be used, etc., and then come back to it about a week later once I’ve created the accounts and site. We spend a full double block learning to log in, changing the appearance of the blog, and learning to post. We generally do the first blog post together. We discuss the elements of a quality blog post—what am I looking for? Points I stress are that it is still for class—correct English grammar must be used. For all intents and purposes, I am their audience (so it should remain as formal writing), and the blog is only for history class. I do not want to read about their weekend experiences on this blog.

    Usually, after a guest speaker they have a blog update to do. Sometimes they turn in an assignment and then I ask them to cut and paste what they have typed and to post it. Other times I have them work as a group to post a response to something in class.

    Points to Consider

    I find that they’re pretty excited about the blogs and they like to write on them. I’ve learned that a clear rubric is key to success—for the students but for my grading as well. Just as any teacher would do for a writing assignment, it is important to lay out the criteria for the post in advance. Am I grading on content? Spelling? Grammar? Reflection? When grading 30 blogs, it becomes ultra important to be able to know what I’m looking for, especially because their posts can vary so much.

    I find that it is important to be very clear with parents about expectations as well.

    Another important note to consider is deadlines. Because students aren’t turning in a physical paper, it’s easy for them to forget deadlines and to overlook them. I find that it’s important to have a final cut-off date for grading blogs . . . along with a lot of reminders. Many parents are not familiar with blogging and so I find that it is important to be very clear with parents about expectations as well. Last year I ran a parent workshop and walked parents through the what, how, and why of blogging so that they could better support their children at home . . . and because I was getting a lot of questions!

    I’m fortunate enough to have a classroom set of laptops and a relatively new and working internet system. However, the number of computers is what has dictated my choices for class blog site vs. small group blog sites. When I started in 2008, I had only two laptops and a desktop, with no permanent and/or regular access to a classroom set of computers.

    My recommendation would be to start small—either with a classroom blog or with a select group of students. Simultaneously, I was blogging on a personal blog and it helped for me to play around with my own blog. I found the Google help site for Blogger very helpful when teaching my students. Pages can be printed and copied for students and then put in their notebooks to be referenced. (Editor's note: If you're using a different blogging service, look for that service's support documentation.)

    The Advantages of Blogging

    For me, blogs are really flexible—for both time and content. While I’ve used them for the duration of a school year, they would be great for a unit project or a semester project. And for those students who are really savvy, it’s a great way to engage them by having them add other multimedia objects to their blogs and to embed links to related content material.

    Just remember to give yourself a head start and don’t be afraid to play around!

    The ideas truly are endless! The winter break and other school breaks really lend themselves to my own exploration time on the blog. It allows me to see what I could implement with my students and to think about how it might further benefit what I am teaching in the classroom. Just remember to give yourself a head start and don’t be afraid to play around! Blogging can be wonderful for both you and the students!

    For more information

    Curious to learn more about blogs and blogging? Our Tech for Teachers entry on blogs looks at some possible platforms, and, in a Teaching Guide, high-school teacher Kyle Smith details one way of using a blog in class.

    Read other ideas from Amy Trenkle in her blog entries on teaching Christopher Columbus with monuments and celebrating the First Amendment.

    Left Behind: Academic Segregation and the Expanding History Education Deficit

    Article Body

    Recently a physical fitness expert came to a local school to work with staff and students on promoting healthy habits. Before leaving he brought forth a pile of prizes to award to students who were able to answer seemingly innocuous questions. One of his questions, “Who can tell me the capital of California?” was met with blank stares. Finally, one brave young man raised his hand, yelling, “I know! Capital C!” Silence resumed until he was awarded the prize for effort and cuteness. After all, technically, he was correct. The scene worsened as adult onlookers audibly groaned, however, when the students were unable to name our nation’s first president.

    Amidst the sadness and humor, the history lovers present recognized the poignancy of the moment: our students often do not even know their geographic location, let alone how we came to be a nation. They might decode words, read short passages, and solve for x in simple equations, but fall short when faced with the task of speaking to other content areas. They learn the basics of what we teach them, gaining the ability to critically tackle tests, moving forward through respective grade levels. In the end, many do not learn the basics of geography, the history of our nation, the importance of civic function, or the meaning of constitutional freedom.

    I see a critical point often overlooked: American schools segregate subjects instead of allowing the natural overlap between them.

    As an educator and teacher trainer I have taught and observed scores of teachers over the years and have witnessed many debates about our national decline in the quality of history education in America. In the past three years, observing in over 300 elementary classrooms, I witnessed little history instruction—but plenty of reading and mathematics and a smattering of science. In time I began informally asking why teachers were not teaching history and received typical answers: no time, too much emphasis on standardized testing, etc. One teacher retorted, “Can I really be expected to teach history when these students can’t speak English and need to pass a reading test at the end of the year?” When it comes to explaining why our students are falling behind in their history education, time-consuming preparation for standardized reading and mathematics testing seemingly reigns supreme on the list of reasons.

    But alas, is testing truly the only culprit here? Among the issues, I see a critical point often overlooked: American schools segregate subjects instead of allowing the natural overlap between them. For example, the single subject of reading currently taught as a skill-based activity through anthologies containing short, irrelevant reading passages, could be instead utilized to teach history and prepare students for civic involvement. Classical Education proponent Leigh Bortins notes that “Whether reciting one of Cicero’s addresses . . . or the Mayflower Compact, since the early 1600s schoolchildren in America were expected to memorize and effectively deliver influential political statements in order to ensure they understood the role of a citizen” (1).

    Truthfully, there is no subject that exists apart from history, an all-encompassing and constantly growing subject.

    We gasp, however, upon encountering the sophisticated language in these classics and primary sources, and for the same reasons we struggle with the language of Shakespeare, we stumble through the documents, speeches, and accounts of history: we simply do not study them, let alone use them to teach reading or serve as models for our own writing. Moreover, if indeed we write the way we speak, one can easily surmise the sharp contrast between our language skills and those of our forefathers, especially in our world of tweeting, texting, and slang. Thus, the chasm widens and we stand little chance of instilling in students the value and skill of using civic language through the characters, plots, and settings of formulaic reading curricula during their daily block of reading instruction. Therein lies a source of major challenge in our schools: American students inherently view reading as an isolated skill rather than a tool invaluable to further learning.

    Truthfully, there is no subject that exists apart from history, an all-encompassing and constantly growing subject. Because every new thought, idea, effort, occurrence, and event becomes a part of its realm, it stands to reason that the less we read, instruct, and learn of the history and legacy of our nation and world, the further behind we fall.

    Footnotes
    (1)L.A. Bortins, The Core: Teaching Your Child the Foundations of Classical Education (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2010).
    Teaser

    Teachers often blame time-consuming standardized testing for the history education deficit; however, school subjects are segregated because we no longer use teaching methods that allow for natural overlaps in content. Specifically, reading should not be a stand-alone subject, but rather, relayed through historic accounts and primary documents to teach history content and model civic language and values.

    Making Difficult Decisions: How Much Do We Value Elementary History Education?

    Article Body
    The district I teach for allots a total of 25 minutes per day for me to cover…more than 400 years of story.

    The condition of history education in elementary schools is conflicted and fragile. I live and teach in the state of Virginia, where the state requires my 4th-grade students to pass an end-of-year 40-question multiple-choice test, which covers all of Virginia history, geography, and economics from 1607 to present day. The district I teach for allots a total of 25 minutes per day for me to cover all that material. Twenty-five minutes a day for more than 400 years of story.

    The Standards of Learning (SOLs) in Virginia were created and implemented about 15 years ago, just at the beginning of my career in 4th grade. As a 4th-grade teacher, my students only had one SOL test to pass: Virginia Studies. We were given 45 minutes daily for social studies. My first year, I had five students out of 25 pass the test, and my class’s passing percentage was the highest of all four 4th grades. According to the promotion/retention policy of my district at the time, a student could be retained solely on the basis of failing that Virginia Studies SOL test. Virginia was very serious about her students knowing her history.

    Over the next decade, I worked hard to raise the bar for both my students and myself. With the support of my administration and my district, I took workshops with the Library of Congress, participated in TAH grants, created teaching materials, learned about using primary sources, and even got some hands-on experience through a teacher institute at Yorktown. I spent my summers and weekends traveling around the state of Virginia scouting out potential field trips, as well as just seeing history up close, photographing and collecting information about all those people and places we were required to teach: Monticello, Gunston Hall, Mount Vernon, Natural Bridge, Luray Caverns, Frontier Culture Museum, Richmond, Skyline Drive, etc. I’m proud to say that as a result of all this effort, our 4th graders have maintained an average of about 85% passing for the past five years.

    But the cold hard fact is that due to No Child Left Behind and my school’s lack of “Adequate Yearly Progress” (AYP), the pendulum has definitely swung away from the focus on history in 4th grade. Now my 4th graders are required to take SOLs in math and reading, in addition to the Virginia Studies test. But it's only the scores for the math and reading that count towards our AYP. Now we are given 25 minutes a day for social studies. I have the skills and the knowledge. I know the curriculum, and I have collected primary sources and created lessons with primary sources as the center. What I don’t have is enough time in the day to actually use the lessons and resources I have. In addition, with the focus on making AYP, nearly all of our resources are going towards programs and materials for math and reading.

    Less money, less resources, less of everything except expectation of what our 4th-grade citizens should know, understand, and be able to explain.

    For example, we used to get money from the district to take our students to Jamestown and Yorktown for a capstone fieldtrip in May. Last year was the first year that we were told that we couldn't have the money for the buses. Consequently, our 4th graders missed the trip. Ironically, last year was also the first year that we were required to implement the revised Virginia Studies SOLs, revised by the state to add content. Less time, more content. Less money, less resources, less of everything except expectation of what our 4th-grade citizens should know, understand, and be able to explain.

    Admittedly, I am an elementary school teacher, so I have most of my students in my classroom all day. In order to cover the Virginia Studies material, I have been making good use of the 50 minutes allotted to writing, and the 75 minutes allotted to reading and integrating social studies into language arts. We have done vocabulary study on words like "underground" which my 4th graders are surprised to learn can mean "secret." We have been reading historical fiction mysteries, biographies, and all those Dear America diaries. We have written biographical essays, and letters to Disney telling them all the historical inaccuracies of their Pocahontas movies.

    In my mind, historical thinking and citizenship are crucial to raising productive, participating, and aware adults.

    But again, two years ago the district adopted a new scripted writing program and so we lost that 50 minutes of writing time. As the district chips away at the flexibility I have in managing my time in my classroom, I lose the ability to integrate the historical thinking and social studies curriculum into other subject areas. The basic problem, as I understand it, is that with a finite amount of time in a school day, something's got to give. It's educational triage; who or what do we make the priority? The federal government tells the state that reading and math are paramount. The state has to follow along or lose federal funding, but they are not willing to let go of their high expectations in the other areas as well. At the district level, we have to answer to both.

    In my school, in my classroom, what's my choice? In my mind, historical thinking and citizenship are crucial to raising productive, participating, and aware adults. So I choose to strive and find ways to teach social studies in a meaningful way. But I am highly trained, passionate about history, and experienced. This year my 4th-grade team alone will take on three new teachers. Without the support of the state, the district, or our administration, and with only 25 minutes a day, what will their choices be?

    Teaser

    As a result of the federal push for qualitative and quantitative skills and the state emphasis on knowledge of regional history, teachers are forced to relay vast amounts of information to their students in a very limited amount of time. Can this issue be solved by extensive teaching preparation? Or is elementary history education beyond repair?

    Elementary History Education: A Bridgeless Chasm

    Article Body

    In U.S. 5th-grade classrooms, students typically study math, language arts, science, physical education and fine arts, and social studies, which is often focused on history from early Atlantic encounters through the American Revolution. In all of these academic and artistic fields, 5th graders engage new material using knowledge and skills they have developed sequentially since kindergarten—that is, in all the fields except history.

    Unlike their experiences in the other disciplines, elementary students do not systematically, year-by-year, learn the heuristics or skills to analyze and interpret historic sources; they are not given the tools to develop historic accounts, grapple with historic causation, or learn historical chronologies; and they are not given opportunities to explore relationships between geography and human experiences over time. The fact that we plunge 5th graders into history without allowing them to develop discipline-specific skills and knowledge in earlier grades suggests that we don’t expect them to study the past with integrity or depth of understanding. Instead of teaching history as an interpretive, evidence-based process that requires discipline-specific skills, we teach it as an exercise in memorizing codified narratives and disembodied dates and facts.

    [BHH] has engaged all K-5 teachers in systematically teaching historical thinking skills on U.S. topics sequentially across the grade levels.

    Since 2001, Teaching American History grants have funded an alternative to the status quo; the Bringing History Home (BHH) K-5 curriculum and professional development project in Iowa. In participating school districts, the project has engaged all K-5 teachers in systematically teaching historical thinking skills on U.S. topics sequentially across the grade levels. K-5 students in BHH classrooms read trade fiction to gain understanding of historical contexts; analyze original sources using an explicit set of heuristics; construct timelines to develop their knowledge of chronologies; illustrate maps with historic events and geographic trends; and construct historic accounts. Formal external evaluations of 3rd through 5th graders in the project have found highly significant student learning outcomes in both historical analysis skills and knowledge of historic events, figures, and eras.

    Case studies of small student groups and individual children in BHH schools have revealed detailed pictures of how 3rd graders can learn and explore history. These studies offer a different picture than does much of the existing research. Previous U.S. research focused on children that had not systematically acquired historical analysis skills, and so researchers concluded either that children cannot accurately infer the meaning of historic images, or will use only material culture cues like clothing or car styles to form inaccurate inferences. In contrast, BHH studies have documented that children can learn historic political and economic concepts and events and use them to interpret unfamiliar history sources. Similarly, in contrast with U.S. and British research that has found students' grasp of historical chronology lacking, BHH studies have documented that children can accurately date and situate unfamiliar events in historic contexts with which they are familiar.

    Even in light of the BHH project evidence for young children's abilities to study history, however, I have little hope that our education system will embrace teaching history systematically in K-5. One of the barriers to this change lies in existing research on K-5 history learning. It has largely failed to document the extent of children's abilities because it has been based on studies of children who have not studied history systematically. Because the research does not allow social studies methods faculty to form accurate expectations for student learning, the faculty cannot prepare teachers to help students reach their potential.

    Another barrier is that in our high-stakes testing era what is tested usually determines what is taught. Multiple-choice tests that can capture middle-elementary children's historical analysis skills have not been designed, and existing social studies multiple-choice standardized tests for 5th graders do not assess historical analysis skills. An overhaul of existing tests to include the skills could provide an impetus for teaching history as evidence-based and interpretive. History testing faces an even more formidable foe, however, and that is the broad disagreement over what should be tested. Because historical interpretation is individual by its nature, and is vulnerable to political manipulation, it provides little or no common ground on which constituents with conflicting values and perspectives can agree.

    ...the current movement to teach information literacy may offer the best hope for a wider adoption of history in K-5.

    Instead of testing, then, the current movement to teach information literacy may offer the best hope for a wider adoption of history in K-5. The skills we use to study the texts of the past also empower us to critically interpret today's ubiquitous online texts. If history professionals joined the U.S. education fray to emphasize that alignment, they might help make the case for history in K-5 classrooms. Meanwhile, in a handful of Iowa BHH school districts, students already systematically study history throughout the elementary grades. In most of the rest of the nation, the gap between what is and what is possible remains a chasm, with no bridge abutments in sight.

    Bibliography

    Kearney, J. et al. Evaluation of the Teaching American History Project: Bringing History Home II. Iowa City: University of Iowa Center for Evaluation and Assessment, 2007.

    Lee, P.J. "Putting Principles into Practice: Understanding History." In How Students Learn: History, Mathematics, and Science in the Classroom, edited by S. Donovan, S. and J. Bransford, J. Washington, DC: National Academies Press, 2005.

    Levstik, L. and Barton, K. Researching History Education: Theory, Method and Context. New York: Routledge, Taylor & Francis group, 2008.

    Levstik, L. & Tyson, C. Handbook of Research in Social Studies Education. New York: Routledge, Taylor & Francis group, 2008.

    Wineburg, S. Historical Thinking and Other Unnatural Acts: Charting the Future of Teaching the Past. Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 2001.

    Teaser

    The current state of history education in elementary schools denies students the right to systematically study the past. However, projects like Bringing History Home and an increased focus on information literacy might be able to fill in the gaps in historical study.

    Transcending Facts to Discover Knowledge

    Article Body

    Too often elementary history education in America consists of only exposing students to who did what, where, and when in hopes they will remember and appreciate it. The common tools employed in this shortsighted approach to history consist of the textbook, trade books, and possibly a video that present the subject in a predigested form where historical thinking has been subtracted from the lesson and replaced with reading skills at best. Little evidence exists to prove the effectiveness of these instruction techniques, but they continue to be used. If student math skills were equal to their history skills, a call for improved strategies would have been made long ago. Think of how often "man on the street" interviews ask a history question just to hear the dumb answers people give. How did we come to the point of asking history questions for humor?

    The reality of testing cannot be ignored, but ignoring history instruction overlooks a valuable test preparation tool.

    The pressure to prepare for state assessments in other subjects overcomes thoughts of implementing innovative techniques that will make history not just memorable but also a vital part of the curriculum. These tests are known to narrow the curriculum, usually at the expense of teaching history. In one study, teachers reported spending 30 minutes per week on social studies instruction while enfolding the subject into novel studies or skills instruction the remainder of the time. One teacher admitted covering social studies "superficially in order to cover the greatest amount of material in the shortest amount of time" (1). The reality of testing cannot be ignored, but ignoring history instruction overlooks a valuable test preparation tool.

    Elementary teachers work hard at their craft, but new ideas need to be considered when it comes to teaching history. If teachers and administrators understood that history involves skills such as investigating texts, objects, and images with questions, then the problem of replacing history lessons with more test preparation time would be solved. History instruction should be seen as something to be done rather than just something to remember.

    The work of historians can be adapted to use in elementary schools as purported by Dr. Bruce Vansledright (2). For instance, in my state instead of focusing a lesson entirely on who fought at the Alamo and the events of those fateful 13 days, students should seek to understand why people would choose to fight against such dire odds and how the battle affected people who were not there. To do so students would have to consult multiple sources. The traditional textbook, trade book, and video formula augmented with a few visual and print primary sources would provide ample resources. In seeking their answers to these subjective questions students would learn the objective information through handling the information for an authentic purpose.

    Most children do not have their curiosity peaked by the prepackaged stories in the textbook, but give them something to argue about and they will dig in.

    Students who are taught to interpret history instead of recalling it will have no trouble answering questions on a reading assessment. Furthermore, teaching students to write out their ideas in an expository form prepares them for writing tests. My students have done similar investigations and their findings have been exciting examples of "doing history." Their test results also show them to be well prepared without completing daily test preparation worksheets.

    Driving history instruction with thought-provoking questions instead of lists of names, events, and stories to memorize gives purpose to learning the past. Most children do not have their curiosity peaked by the prepackaged stories in the textbook, but give them something to argue about and they will dig in. And if they happen to be thinking critically while they do it, doesn't it make us all winners in the end?

    Footnotes
    1 S. Burroughs, E. Groce, and M.L. Webeck, "Social Studies Education in the Age of Testing and Accountability," Educational Measurement: Issues and Practice (2005): 13–20.
    2 B. Vansledright, "Can Ten-Year Olds Learn to Investigate History As Historians Do?," Organization of American Historians Newsletter August (2000).
    Teaser

    Elementary history education lies in need of a paradigm shift. In a time when critical thinking and problem solving drive instruction, educators need to realize history provides an avenue to practice these skills.