New Mexico: 9th-Grade Standards

Article Body

(Note: By the completion of grades 9–12, Oregon students are expected to master the following standards.)

  • Strand: History

    Content Standard I: Students are able to identify important people and events in order to analyze significant patterns, relationships, themes, ideas, beliefs, and turning points in New Mexico, United States, and world history in order to understand the complexity of the human experience. Students will:

    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark I-A—New Mexico:

      Analyze how people and events of New Mexico have influenced United States and world history since statehood.

      Performance Standards

      1. Compare and contrast the relationships over time of Native American tribes in New Mexico with other cultures.
      2. Analyze the geographic, economic, social and political factors of New Mexico that impact United States and world history, to include:
        • a. land grant and treaty issues unresolved to present day and continuing to impact relations between and among citizens at the state, tribal and federal government levels;
        • b. role of water issues as they relate to development of industry, population growth, historical issues and current acequia systems/water organizations;
        • c. urban development;
        • d. role of the federal government (e.g., military bases, national laboratories, national parks, Indian reservations, transportation systems, water projects);
        • e. unique role of New Mexico in the 21st century as a ìminority majorityî state.
      3. Analyze the role and impact of New Mexico and New Mexicans in World War II (e.g., Navajo code talkers, New Mexico national guard, internment camps, Manhattan project, Bataan death march).
      4. Analyze the impact of the arts, sciences and technology of New Mexico since World War II (e.g., artists, cultural artifacts, nuclear weapons, the arms race, technological advances, scientific developments, high-tech industries, federal laboratories).
      5. Explain how New Mexico history represents a framework of knowledge and skills within which to understand the complexity of the human experience, to include: analyze perspectives that have shaped the structures of historical knowledge; describe ways historians study the past; explain connections made between the past and the present and their impact.
    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark I-B—United States:

      Analyze and evaluate the impact of major eras, events and individuals in United States history since the civil war and reconstruction.

      Performance Standards

      1. Analyze the impact and changes that reconstruction had on the historical, political and social development of the United States.
      2. Analyze the transformation of the American economy and the changing social and political conditions in the United States in response to the industrial revolution, including:
        • a. innovations in technology, evolution of marketing techniques, changes to the standard of living and the rise of consumer culture;
        • b. rise of business leaders and their companies as major forces in America (e.g., John D. Rockefeller, Andrew Carnegie);
        • c. development of monopolies and their impact on economic and political policies (e.g., laissez-faire economics, trusts, trust busting);
        • d. growth of cities (e.g., influx of immigrants, rural-to-urban migrations, racial and ethnic conflicts that resulted);
        • e. efforts of workers to improve working conditions (e.g., organizing labor unions, strikes, strike breakers);
        • f. rise and effect of reform movements (e.g., Populists, William Jennings Bryan, Jane Addams, muckrakers);
        • g. conservation of natural resources (e.g., the Grand Canyon, Yellowstone, Anasazi ruins at Mesa Verde, Colorado, National Reclamation Act of 1902);
        • h. progressive reforms (e.g., the national income tax, direct election of senators, womenís suffrage, prohibition).
      3. Analyze the United Statesí expanding role in the world during the late 19th and 20th centuries, to include:
        • a. causes for a change in foreign policy from isolationism to interventionism; causes and consequences of the Spanish American war;
        • b. expanding influence in the western hemisphere (e.g., the Panama canal, Roosevelt corollary added to the Monroe doctrine, the ìbig stickî policy, ìdollar diplomacyî);
        • c. events that led to the United Statesí involvement in World War I; United Statesí rationale for entry into World War I and impact on military process, public opinion and policy;
        • d. United Statesí mobilization in World War I (e.g., its impact on politics, economics and society);
        • e. United Statesí impact on the outcome of World War I; United Statesí role in settling the peace (e.g., Woodrow Wilson, treaty of Versailles, league of nations, Senator Henry Cabot Lodge, Sr.).
      4. Analyze the major political, economic and social developments that occurred between World War I and World War II, to include:
        • a. social liberation and conservative reaction during the 1920s (e.g., flappers, prohibition, the Scopes trial, the red scare);
        • b. causes of the great depression (e.g., over production, under consumption, credit structure);
        • c. rise of youth culture in the ìjazz ageî;
        • d. development of mass/popular culture (e.g., rise of radio, movies, professional sports, popular literature);
        • e. human and natural crises of the great depression, (e.g., unemployment, food lines, the dust bowl, western migration of midwest farmers);
        • f. changes in policies, role of government and issues that emerged from the new deal (e.g., the works programs, social security, challenges to the supreme court);
        • g. role of changing demographics on traditional communities and social structures.
      5. Analyze the role of the United States in World War II, to include:
        • a. reasons the United States moved from a policy of isolationism to involvement after the bombing of Pearl Harbor;
        • b. events on the home front to support the war effort (e.g., war bond drives, mobilization of the war industry, women and minorities in the work force);
        • c. major turning points in the war (e.g., the battle of Midway, D-Day invasion, dropping of atomic bombs on Japan).
      6. Analyze the development of voting and civil rights for all groups in the United States following reconstruction, to include:
        • a. intent and impact of the 13th, 14th and 15th Amendments to the constitution;
        • b. segregation as enforced by Jim Crow laws following reconstruction;
        • c. key court cases (e.g., Plessy v. Ferguson, Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, Roe v. Wade);
        • d. roles and methods of civil rights advocates (e.g., Martin Luther King, Jr., Malcolm X, Rosa Parks, Russell Means, CÈsar Ch·vez);
        • e. the passage and effect of the voting rights legislation on minorities (e.g., 19th amendment, role of Arizona supreme court decision on Native Americans, their disenfranchisement under Arizona constitution and subsequent changes made in other state constitutions regarding Native American voting rights - such as New Mexico, 1962, 1964 Civil Rights Act, Voting Act of 1965, 24th Amendment);
        • f. impact and reaction to the efforts to pass the Equal Rights Amendment;
        • g. rise of black power, brown power, American Indian movement, united farm workers.
      7. Analyze the impact of World War II and the cold war on United Statesí foreign and domestic policy, to include:
        • a. origins, dynamics and consequences of the cold war tensions between the United States and the Soviet Union;
        • b. new role of the United States as a world leader (e.g., Marshall plan, NATO);
        • c. need for, establishment and support of the united nations;
        • d. implementation of the foreign policy of containment, including the Truman doctrine;
        • e. Red Scare (e.g., McCarthyism, House Un-American Activities Committee, nuclear weapons, arms race);
        • f. external confrontations with communism (e.g., the Berlin blockade, Berlin wall, Bay of Pigs, Cuban missile crisis, Korea, Vietnam war);
        • g. Sputnik and the space race;
        • h. image of 1950s affluent society;
        • i. political protests of Vietnam war);
        • j. counterculture in the 1960s.
      8. Analyze the impact of the post-cold war Era on United Statesí foreign policy, to include:
        • a. role of the United States in supporting democracy in eastern Europe following the collapse of the Berlin wall;
        • b. new allegiances in defining the new world order;
        • c. role of technology in the information age.
      9. Explain how United States history represents a framework of knowledge and skills within which to understand the complexity of the human experience, to include:
        • a. analyze perspectives that have shaped the structures of historical knowledge;
        • b. describe ways historians study the past;
        • c. explain connections made between the past and the present and their impact.
    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark I-C—World:

      Analyze and interpret the major eras and important turning points in world history from the age of enlightenment to the present, to develop an understanding of the complexity of the human experience.

      Performance Standards

      1. Describe and explain how the renaissance and reformation influenced education, art, religion and government in Europe, to include:
        • a. development of renaissance artistic and literary traditions (e.g., Michelangelo, Leonardo da Vinci, Shakespeare);
        • b. development of protestantism (e.g., Martin Luther, John Calvin);
        • c. religious conflict and persecutions (e.g., Spanish inquisition).
      2. Analyze and evaluate the actions of competing European nations for colonies around the world and the impact on indigenous populations;
      3. Explain and analyze revolutions (e.g., democratic, scientific, technological, social) as they evolved throughout the enlightenment and their enduring effects on political, economic and cultural institutions, to include:
        • a. Copernican view of the universe and Newtonís natural laws;
        • b. tension and cooperation between religion and new scientific discoveries;
        • c. impact of Galileoís ideas and the introduction of the scientific method as a means of understanding the universe;
        • d. events and ideas that led to parliamentary government (English civil war, glorious revolution);
        • e. enlightenment philosophies used to support events leading to American and French revolutions;
        • f. Napoleonic era (e.g., codification of law); Latin Americaís wars of independence.
      4. Analyze the pattern of historical change as evidenced by the industrial revolution, to include:
        • a. conditions that promoted industrialization;
        • b. how scientific and technological innovations brought about change;
        • c. impact of population changes (e.g., population growth, rural-to-urban migrations, growth of industrial cities, emigration out of Europe);
        • d. evolution of work/business and the role of labor (e.g., the demise of slavery, division of labor, union movement, impact of immigration);
        • e. political and economic theories of capitalism and socialism (e.g., Adam Smith, Karl Marx);
        • f. status and roles of women and minorities.
      5. Analyze and evaluate the impact of 19th century imperialism from varied perspectives, to include:
        • a. clash of cultures;
        • b. British empire expands around the world;
        • c. nationalism (e.g., competition and conflict between European nations for raw materials and markets, acquisition of colonies in Africa and Asia, impact on indigenous populations).
      6. Describe and analyze the geographic, political, economic, religious and social structures of the civilizations of east Asia;
      7. Analyze and evaluate the causes, events and effects of World War I, to include:
        • a. rise of nationalism (e.g., unification of Germany, Otto Von Bismarckís leadership);
        • b. rise of ethnic and ideological conflicts (e.g., the Balkans, Austria-Hungary, decline of the Ottoman empire);
        • c. major turning points and the importance of geographic, military and political factors in decisions and outcomes;
        • d. human costs of the mechanization of war (e.g., machine-gun, airplane, poison gas, submarine, trench warfare, tanks);
        • e. effects of loss of human potential through devastation of populations and their successive generations;
        • f. effects of the Russian revolution and the implementation of communist rule.
      8. Analyze and evaluate the causes, events and impacts of World War II from various perspectives, to include:
        • a. failures and successes of the treaty of Versailles and the league of nations; rise of totalitarianism (e.g., Nazi Germanyís policies of European domination, holocaust);
        • b. political, diplomatic and military leadership (e.g., Winston Churchill, Joseph Stalin, Franklin Roosevelt, Emperor Hirohito, Adolf Hitler, Benito Mussolini, Francisco Franco);
        • c. principal theaters of battle, major turning points and geographic factors in military decisions and outcomes (e.g., Pearl Harbor, ìisland-hopping,î D-Day invasion, Stalingrad, atomic bombs dropped on Japan).
      9. Analyze and evaluate international developments following World War II, the cold war and post-cold war, to include:
        • a. war crime trials;
        • b. creation of the state of Israel and resulting conflicts in the middle east;
        • c. rebuilding of western Europe (e.g., Marshall Plan, NATO);
        • d. Soviet control of eastern Europe (e.g., Warsaw pact, Hungarian revolt);
        • e. creation and role of the united nations;
        • f. Mao Zedong and the Chinese revolution (e.g., long march, Taiwan, cultural revolution);
        • g. national security in the changing world order;
        • h. technologyís role in ending the cold war;
        • i. fluidity of political alliances;
        • j. new threats to peace;
        • k. reasons for the collapse of the Soviet Union and the end of the cold war;
        • l. use of technology in the information age.
      10. Evaluate the ideologies and outcomes of independence movements in the emerging third world to include:
        • a. French Indochina and the Vietnam war (e.g., the role of Ho Chi Minh);
        • b. Mohandas Gandhiís non-violence movement for Indiaís independence;
        • c. apartheid in South Africa and evolution from white minority government (e.g., Nelson Mandela, Desmond Tutu);
        • d. middle east conflicts (Israel, Palestine, Egypt).
      11. Analyze historical and modern-day policies of the western hemisphere, with emphasis on Mexico and Canada, to include:
        • a. expansion of democracy in western hemisphere;
        • b. immigration and migration issues;
        • c. changes in foreign policy brings spiraling impact on each nation and international relations, trade.
      12. Explain how world history presents a framework of knowledge and skills within which to understand the complexity of the human experience, to include:
        • a. analyze perspectives that have shaped the structures of historical knowledge;
        • b. describe ways historians study the past;
        • c. explain connections made between the past and the present and their impact.
    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark I-D—Skills:

      Use critical thinking skills to understand and communicate perspectives of individuals, groups and societies from multiple contexts.

      Performance Standards

      1. Understand how to use the skills of historical analysis to apply to current social, political, geographic and economic issues.
      2. Apply chronological and spatial thinking to understand the importance of events.
      3. Describe primary and secondary sources and their uses in research.
      4. Explain how to use a variety of historical research methods and documents to interpret and understand social issues (e.g., the friction among societies, the diffusion of ideas).
      5. Distinguish ìfactsî from authorsí opinions and evaluate an authorís implicit and explicit philosophical assumptions, beliefs or biases about the subject.
      6. Interpret events and issues based upon the historical, economic, political, social and geographic context of the participants.
      7. Analyze the evolution of particular historical and contemporary perspectives.
      8. Explain how to use technological tools to research data, verify facts and information, and communicate findings.
  • Strand: Geography

    Content Standard II: Students understand how physical, natural, and cultural processes influence where people live, the ways in which people live, and how societies interact with one another and their environments. Students will:

    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark II-A:

      Analyze and evaluate the characteristics and purposes of geographic tools, knowledge, skills, and perspectives and apply them to explain the past, present and future in terms of patterns, events and issues.

      Performance Standards

      1. Evaluate and select appropriate geographic representations to analyze and explain natural and man-made issues and problems.
      2. Understand the vocabulary and concepts of spatial interaction, including an analysis of population distributions and settlement patterns.
    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark II-B:

      Analyze natural and man-made characteristics of worldwide locales; describe regions, their interrelationships and patterns of change.

      Performance Standards

      1. Analyze the interrelationships among natural and human processes that shape the geographic connections and characteristics of regions, including connections among economic development, urbanization, population growth and environmental change.
      2. Analyze how the character and meaning of a place is related to its economic, social and cultural characteristics, and why diverse groups in society view places and regions differently.
      3. Analyze and evaluate changes in regions and recognize the patterns and causes of those changes (e.g., mining, tourism).
      4. Analyze and evaluate why places and regions are important to human identity (e.g., sacred tribal grounds, culturally unified neighborhoods).
    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark II-C:

      Analyze the impact of people, places and natural environments upon the past and present in terms of our ability to plan for the future.

      Performance Standards

      1. Analyze the fundamental role that geography has played in human history (e.g., the Russian winter on the defeat of Napoleonís army and the same effect in World War II).
      2. Compare and contrast how different viewpoints influence policy regarding the use and management of natural resources.
      3. Analyze the role that spatial relationships have played in effecting historic events.
      4. Analyze the use of and effectiveness of technology in the study of geography.
    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark II-D:

      Analyze how physical processes shape the earthís surface patterns and biosystems.

      Performance Standards

      1. Analyze how the earthís physical processes are dynamic and interactive.
      2. Analyze the importance of ecosystems in understanding environments.
      3. Explain and analyze how water is a scare resource in New Mexico, both in quantity and quality.
      4. Explain the dynamics of the four basic components of the earthís physical systems (atmosphere, biosphere, lithosphere and hydrosphere).
    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark II-E:

      Analyze and evaluate how economic, political, cultural and social processes interact to shape patterns of human populations and their interdependence, cooperation and conflict.

      Performance Standards

      1. Analyze the factors influencing economic activities (e.g., mining, ranching, agriculture, tribal gaming, tourism, high tech) that have resulted in New Mexicoís population growth.
      2. Analyze the effects of geographic factors on major events in United States and world history.
      3. Analyze the interrelationships among settlement, migration, population-distribution patterns, land forms and climates in developing and developed countries.
      4. How cooperation and conflict are involved in shaping the distribution of political, social and economic factors in New Mexico, United States and throughout the world (e.g., land grants, border issues, United States territories, Israel and the middle east, the former Soviet Union, and Sub-Saharan Africa).
      5. Analyze how cultures shape characteristics of a region.
      6. Analyze how differing points of view and self-interest play a role in conflict over territory and resources (e.g., impact of culture, politics, strategic locations, resources).
      7. Evaluate the effects of technology on the developments, changes to, and interactions of cultures.
    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark II-F:

      Analyze and evaluate the effects of human and natural interactions in terms of changes in the meaning, use, distribution and importance of resources in order to predict our global capacity to support human activity.

      Performance Standards

      1. Compare the ways man-made and natural processes modify the environment and how these modifications impact resource allocations.
      2. Analyze how environmental changes bring about and impact resources.
      3. Analyze the geographic factors that influence the major world patterns of economic activity, economic connections among different regions, changing alignments in world trade partners and the potential redistribution of resources based on changing patterns and alignments.
  • Strand: Civics and Government

    Content Standard III: Students understand the ideals, rights, and responsibilities of citizenship and understand the content and history of the founding documents of the United States with particular emphasis on the United States and New Mexico constitutions and how governments function at local, state, tribal, and national levels. Students will:

    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark III-A:

      Compare and analyze the structure, power and purpose of government at the local, state, tribal and national levels as set forth in their respective constitutions or governance documents.

      Performance Standards

      1. Analyze the structure, powers and role of the legislative branch of the United States government, to include: specific powers delegated in Article I of the constitution; checks and balances described in the federalist papers, Number 51; lawmaking process; role of leadership within congress; federalist and antifederalist positions.
      2. Analyze the structure, powers and role of the executive branch of the United States government, to include: specific powers delegated in Article II of the constitution; checks and balances; development of the cabinet and federal bureaucracy; roles and duties of the presidency, including those acquired over time such as ìhead of stateî and ìhead of a political party.î
      3. Examine the election of the president through the nomination process, national conventions and electoral college.
      4. Analyze the structure, powers and role of the judicial branch of the United States government, including landmark United States supreme court decisions, to include: specific powers delegated by the Constitution in Article III and described in the federalist papers, Numbers 78-83; checks and balances; judicial review as developed in Marbury v. Madison; issues raised in McCulloch v. Maryland; dual court system of state and federal governments, including their organization and jurisdiction.
      5. Analyze the rights, protections, limits and freedoms included within the United States constitution and bill of rights, to include: constitutional mandates such as the right of habeas corpus, no bill of attainder and the prohibition of the ex post facto laws; 1st Amendment guarantees freedom of religion, speech, press, assembly, and petition; 4th, 5th and 6th Amendments address search and seizure, rights of the accused, right to a fair and speedy trial, and other legal protections; 14th Amendment protection of due process and equal protection under the law; conflicts which occur between rights, including tensions between the right to a fair trial and freedom of the press and between majority rule and individual rights; expansion of voting rights, limitation of presidential terms, etc.
      6. Compare and contrast the structure and powers of New Mexicoís government as expressed in the New Mexico constitution with that of the United States constitution, to include: direct democracy in the initiative, referendum and recall process; impeachment process; process of voter registration and voting; role of primary elections to nominate candidates; how a bill becomes a law; executive officers and their respective powers; New Mexico courts, appointment of judges, and election and retainment processes for judges; organization of county and municipal governments.
      7. Describe and analyze the powers and responsibilities (including the concept of legitimate power) of local, state, tribal and national governments.
    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark III-B:

      Analyze how the symbols, icons, songs, traditions and leaders of New Mexico and the United States exemplify ideals and provide continuity and a sense of unity.

      Performance Standards

      1. Analyze the qualities of effective leadership.
      2. Evaluate the impact of United States political, tribal and social leaders on New Mexico and the nation.
      3. Analyze the contributions of symbols, songs and traditions toward promoting a sense of unity at the state and national levels.
      4. Evaluate the role of New Mexico and United States symbols, icons, songs and traditions in providing continuity over time.
    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark III-C:

      Compare and contrast the philosophical foundations of the United Statesí political system in terms of the purpose of government, including its historical sources and ideals, with those of other governments in the world.

      Performance Standards

      1. Analyze the structure, function and powers of the federal government (e.g., legislative, executive, and judicial branches).
      2. Analyze and explain the philosophical foundations of the American political system in terms of the inalienable rights of people and the purpose of government, to include: Iroquois league and its organizational structure for effective governance; basic philosophical principles of John Locke expressed in the second treatise of government (nature, equality, and dissolution of government); foundation principles of laws by William Blackstone (laws in general and absolute rights of individuals); importance of the founders of the rights of Englishmen, the Magna Carta and representative government in England.
      3. Analyze the fundamental principles in the declaration of independence.
      4. Analyze the historical sources and ideals of the structure of the United States government, to include: principles of democracy; essential principles of a republican form of government; code of law put forth in the Code of Hammurabi; separation of powers as expressed by the Baron of Montesquieu; checks and balances as expressed by Thomas Hobbs; ideas of individual rights developed in the English bill of rights; role of philosophers in supporting changes in governments in the 18th and 19th centuries (e.g., Locke, Rousseau, Voltaire).
      5. Compare and contrast the concepts of courts and justice from Henry II of England to the court system of today.
      6. Compare and contrast the unitary, confederal and federal systems.
      7. Analyze the ways powers are distributed and shared in a parliamentary system.
      8. Compare and contrast the different philosophies, structures and institutions of democratic versus totalitarian systems of government.
      9. Analyze and evaluate the concept of limited government and the rule of law.
      10. Compare and contrast the characteristics of representative governments.
      11. Compare and contrast characteristics of Native American governments with early United States government.
      12. Compare and contrast the philosophical foundations of forms of government to understand the purpose of the corresponding political systems (e.g., socialism, capitalism, secular, theocratic, totalitarian).
      13. Analyze the role that the United States has played as a constitutional republican government for nations around the world.
    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark III- D:

      Understand how to exercise rights and responsibilities as citizens by participating in civic life and using skills that include interacting, monitoring and influencing.

      Performance Standards

      1. Describe and analyze the influence of the non-elected (e.g., staff, lobbyists, interest groups).
      2. Analyze the rights and obligations of citizens in the United States, to include: connections between self-interest, the common good and the essential element of civic virtue, as described in the federalist papers, Numbers 5 and 49; obeying the law, serving on juries, paying taxes, voting, registering for selective service and military service.
      3. Demonstrate the skills needed to participate in government at all levels, including: analyze public issues and the political system; evaluate candidates and their positions; debate current issues.
      4. Analyze factors that influence the formation of public opinion (e.g., media, print, advertising, news broadcasts, magazines, radio).
      5. Evaluate standards, conflicts and issues related to universal human rights and their impact on public policy.
  • Strand: Economics

    Content Standard IV: Students understand basic economic principles and use economic reasoning skills to analyze the impact of economic systems (including the market economy) on individuals, families, businesses, communities, and governments. Students will:

    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark IV-A:

      Analyze the ways individuals, households, businesses, governments and societies make decisions, are influenced by incentives (economic and intrinsic) and the availability and use of scarce resources, and that their choices involve costs and varying ways of allocating.

      Performance Standards

      1. Analyze ìopportunity costsî as a factor resulting from the process of decision making.
      2. Understand how socioeconomic stratification (SES) arises and how it affects human motivation, using data.
      3. Understand the relationship between socioeconomic stratification and cultural values.
      4. Analyze and evaluate the impact of economic choices on the allocation of scarce resources.
      5. Describe and analyze how economic incentives allow individuals, households, businesses, governments and societies to use scarce human, financial and natural resources more efficiently to meet economic goals.
      6. Evaluate present and future economic costs and economic risks in the use of productive resources associated with investments.
      7. Understand labor markets and how they work.
      8. Describe and analyze the three major divisions of economics: macro-, micro- and consumer.
      9. Understand the relationship between essential learning skills and workforce requirements (e.g., school to work initiatives, service learning) as they relate to supply and demand in the labor market.
      10. Use quantitative data to analyze economic information.
      11. Analyze various investment strategies available when meeting personal and business goals.
      12. Understand the basis of supply and demand and marginal productivity.
      13. Understand personal financing (e.g., banking, credit, debit, lending institutions).
    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark IV-B:

      Analyze and evaluate how economic systems impact the way individuals, households, businesses, governments and societies make decisions about resources and the production and distribution of goods and services.

      Performance Standards

      1. Analyze the historic origins of the economic systems of capitalism, socialism and communism.
      2. Compare the relationships between and among contemporary countries with differing economic systems.
      3. Understand the distribution and characteristics of economic systems throughout the world, to include: (e.g., characteristics of command, market, and traditional economies; how command, market and traditional economies operate in specific countries; comparison of the ways that people satisfy their basic needs through the production of goods and services).
      4. Analyze the importance of, and issues related to the location and management of the factors of production.
      5. Describe how changes in technology, transportation and communication affect the location and patterns of economic activities in New Mexico and the United States.
      6. Analyze the roles played by local, state, tribal and national governments in both public and private sectors of the United States system.
      7. Understand the relationship between the United States' governmental policies and international trade.
      8. Evaluate economic systems by their ability to achieve broad societal goals (e.g., efficiency, equity, security, employment, stability, economic growth).
      9. Explain how businesses (e.g., sole proprietorships, partnerships, corporations, franchises) are organized and financed in the United States economy.
      10. Interpret measurements of inflation and unemployment and relate them to the general economic "health" of the national economy.
      11. Analyze the impact of fiscal policy on an economic system (e.g., deficit, surplus, inflation).
      12. Compare and contrast different types of taxes (e.g., progressive, regressive, proportional).
      13. Analyze the effects of specific government regulations on different economically- designated groups (e.g., consumers, employees, businesses).
      14. Compare, analyze and evaluate the positive and negative aspects of American capitalism in relationship to other economic systems.
      15. Describe and evaluate how the United States economy moved from being manufacturing-based to information-driven.
      16. Analyze the reasons for uneven economic growth-based changes (e.g., demographic, political, economic).
      17. Analyze the economic ramifications of entrepreneurship.
    • Grade 9-12 Benchmark IV-C:

      Analyze and evaluate the patterns and results of trade, exchange and interdependence between the United States and the world since 1900.

      Performance Standards

      1. Analyze foreign and domestic issues related to United States economic growth since 1900.
      2. Analyze significant economic developments between World War I and World War II, to include: economic growth and prosperity of the 1920s; causes of the great depression and the effects on United States economy and government; new deal measures enacted to counter the great depression; expansion of government under new deal.
      3. Analyze the effects of World War II, the cold war and post-cold war on contemporary society, to include: economic effects of World War II on the home front; United States prosperity of the 1950s; impact of the cold war on business cycle and defense spending; recession of 1980s; technology boom and consequent economic slow-down of 2000.
      4. Describe the relationship between the United States' international trade policies and its economic system.
      5. Identify and analyze the international differences in resources, productivity and prices that are a basis for international trade.
      6. Explain the comparative advantage of a nation when it can produce a product at a lower "opportunity cost" than its trading partner.
      7. Evaluate the effect on international trade of domestic policies that either encourage or discourage exchange of goods and services and investments abroad.
      8. Analyze and evaluate how domestic policies can affect the balance of trade between nations.
      9. Explain and describe how the federal reserve system and monetary policies (e.g., open market, discount rate, change in reserve requirements) are used to promote price stability, maximum employment, and economic growth.
      10. Identify how monetary policies can affect exchange rates and international trade.
      11. Analyze and evaluate the use of technology affecting economic development.
      12. Describe and analyze multinational entities (e.g., NAFTA, European Union) in economic and social terms.

Ohio: 9th-Grade Standards

Article Body

The Social Studies Academic Content Standards revision contains syllabi for six high school social studies courses: American History, Modern World History, American Government, Economics and Financial Literacy, Contemporary World Issues and World Geography. Each contains a course and broad topics which are further clarified with content statements. Grade levels are not specified for any of the courses.

The syllabi, adopted by the State Board of Education in 2010, are available for districts to use as they plan course offerings. Three units of social studies credit are required for graduation from high school, including a half unit of credit in American History and a half unit of credit in American Government. No decision has been made yet about connecting specific courses to end-of-course exams. The inclusion of particular courses in the standards is not meant to require that all of these courses be offered or limit the choice of courses which districts may offer in their social studies programs.

American History

Theme: This course examines the history of the United States of America from 1877 to the present. The federal republic has withstood challenges to its national security and expanded the rights and roles of its citizens. The episodes of its past have shaped the nature of the country today and prepared it to attend to the challenges of tomorrow. Understanding how these events came to pass and their meaning for today’s citizens is the purpose of this course. The concepts of historical thinking introduced in earlier grades continue to build with students locating and analyzing primary and secondary sources from multiple perspectives to draw conclusions.

  • Topic: Historical Thinking and Skills

    Students apply skills by utilizing a variety of resources to construct theses and support or refute contentions made by others. Alternative explanations of historical events are analyzed and questions of historical inevitability are explored.

    Content Statements

    • 1. Historical events provide opportunities to examine alternative courses of action..
    • 2. The use of primary and secondary sources of information includes an examination of the credibility of each source.
    • 3. Historians develop theses and use evidence to support or refute positions.
    • 4. Historians analyze cause, effect, sequence, and correlation in historical events,
      including multiple causation and long- and short-term causal relations.
  • Topic: Industrialization and Progressivism (1877-1920)

    Ignited by post-Civil War demand and fueled by technological advancements, large-scale industrialization began in the United States during the late 1800s. Growing industries enticed foreign immigration, fostered urbanization, gave rise to the American labor movement and developed the infrastructure that facilitated the settling of the West. A period of progressive reform emerged in response to political corruption and practices of big business.

    Content Statements

    • 5. The rise of corporations, heavy industry, mechanized farming and technological innovations transformed the American economy from an agrarian to an increasingly urban industrial society.
    • 6. The rise of industrialization led to a rapidly expanding workforce. Labor organizations grew amidst unregulated working conditions, laissez-faire policies toward big business, and violence toward supporters of organized labor.
    • 7. Immigration, internal migration and urbanization transformed American life.
    • 8. Following Reconstruction, old political and social structures reemerged and racial discrimination was institutionalized.
    • 9. The Progressive era was an effort to address the ills of American society stemming from industrial capitalism, urbanization and political corruption.
  • Topic: Foreign Affairs from Imperialism to Post-World War I (1898-1930)

    The industrial and territorial growth of the United States fostered expansion overseas. Greater involvement in the world set the stage for American participation in World War I and attempts to preserve post-war peace.

    Content Statements

    • 10. As a result of overseas expansion, the Spanish-American War and World War I, the United States emerged as a world power.
    • 11. After WWI, the United States pursued efforts to maintain peace in the world. However, as a result of the national debate over the Versailles Treaty ratification and the League of Nations, the United States moved away from the role of world peacekeeper and limited its involvement in international affairs.
  • Topic: Prosperity, Depression and the New Deal (1919-1941)

    The post-World War I period was characterized by economic, social and political turmoil. Post- war prosperity brought about changes to American popular culture. However, economic disruptions growing out the war years led to worldwide depression. The United States attempted to deal with the Great Depression through economic programs created by the federal government.

    Content Statements

    • 12. Racial intolerance, anti-immigrant attitudes and the Red Scare contributed to social unrest after World War I.
    • 13. An improved standard of living for many, combined with technological innovations in communication, transportation and industry, resulted in social and cultural changes and tensions.
    • 14. Movements such as the Harlem Renaissance, African-American migration, women’s suffrage and Prohibition all contributed to social change.
    • 15. The Great Depression was caused, in part, by the federal government’s monetary policies, stock market speculation, and increasing consumer debt. The role of the federal government expanded as a result of the Great Depression.
  • Topic: From Isolation to World War (1930-1945)

    The isolationist approach to foreign policy meant U.S. leadership in world affairs diminished after World War I. Overseas, certain nations saw the growth of tyrannical governments which reasserted their power through aggression and created conditions leading to the Second World War. After Pearl Harbor, the United States entered World War II, which changed the country’s focus from isolationism to international involvement.

    Content Statements

    • 16. During the 1930s, the U.S. government attempted to distance the country from earlier interventionist policies in the Western Hemisphere as well as retain an isolationist approach to events in Europe and Asia until the beginning of WWII.
    • 17. The United States mobilization of its economic and military resources during World War II brought significant changes to American society.
    • 18. Use of atomic weapons changed the nature of war, altered the balance of power and began the nuclear age.
  • Topic: The Cold War (1945-1991)

    The United States and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (U.S.S.R.) emerged as the two strongest powers in international affairs. Ideologically opposed, they challenged one another in a series of confrontations known as the Cold War. The costs of this prolonged contest weakened the U.S.S.R. so that it collapsed due to internal upheavals as well as American pressure. The Cold War had social and political implications in the United States.

    Content Statements

    • 19. The United States followed a policy of containment during the Cold War in response to the spread of communism.
    • 20. The Second Red Scare and McCarthyism reflected Cold War fears in American society.
    • 21. The Cold War and conflicts in Korea and Vietnam influenced domestic and international politics.
    • 22. The collapse of communist governments in Eastern Europe and the U.S.S.R. brought an end to the Cold War.
  • Topic: Social Transformations in the United States (1945-1994)

    A period of post-war prosperity allowed the United States to undergo fundamental social change. Adding to this change was an emphasis on scientific inquiry, the shift from an industrial to a technological/service economy, the impact of mass media, the phenomenon of suburban and Sun Belt migrations, the increase in immigration and the expansion of civil rights.

    Content Statements

    • 23. Following World War II, the United States experienced a struggle for racial and gender equality and the extension of civil rights.
    • 24. The postwar economic boom, greatly affected by advances in science, produced epic changes in American life.
    • 25. The continuing population flow from cities to suburbs, the internal migrations from the Rust Belt to the Sun Belt, and the increase in immigration resulting from passage of the 1965 Immigration Act have had social and political effects.
    • 26. Political debates focused on the extent of the role of government in the economy, environmental protection, social welfare and national security.
  • Topic: United States and the Post-Cold War World (1991 to Present)

    The United States emerged from the Cold War as a dominant leader in world affairs amidst a globalized economy, political terrorism and the proliferation of nuclear weapons.

    Content Statements

    • 27. Improved global communications, international trade, transnational business organizations, overseas competition and the shift from manufacturing to service industries have impacted the American economy.
    • 28. The United States faced new political, national security and economic challenges in the post-Cold War world and following the attacks on September 11, 2001.

American Government

Theme: How the American people govern themselves at national, state and local levels of government is the basis for this course. Students can impact issues addressed by local governments through service learning and senior projects.

  • Topic: Civic Involvement

    Students can engage societal problems and participate in opportunities to contribute to the common good through governmental and nongovernmental channels.

    Content Statements

    • 1. Opportunities for civic engagement with the structures of government are made possible through political and public policy processes.
    • 2. Political parties, interest groups and the media provide opportunities for civic involvement through various means.
  • Topic: Civic Participation and Skills

    Democratic government is enhanced when individuals exercise the skills to effectively participate in civic affairs.

    Content Statements

    • 3. Issues can be analyzed through the critical use of information from public records, surveys, research data and policy positions of advocacy groups.
    • 4. The processes of persuasion, compromise, consensus building and negotiation contribute to the resolution of conflicts and differences.
  • Topic: Basic Principles of the U.S. Constitution

    Principles related to representative democracy are reflected in the articles and amendments of the U.S. Constitution and provide structure for the government of the United States.

    Content Statements

    • 5. As the supreme law of the land, the U.S. Constitution incorporates basic principles which help define the government of the United States as a federal republic including its structure, powers and relationship with the governed.
    • 6. Constitutional government in the United States has changed over time as a result of amendments to the U.S. Constitution, Supreme Court decisions, legislation and informal practices.
  • Topic: Structure and Functions of the Federal Government

    Three branches compose the basic structure of the federal government. Public policy is created through the making of laws, the execution of the laws and the adjudication of disputes under the laws.

    Content Statements

    • 7. Law and public policy are created and implemented by three branches of government; each functions with its own set of powers and responsibilities.
    • 8. The political process creates a dynamic interaction among the three branches of government in addressing current issues.
  • Topic: Role of the People

    The government of the United States protects the freedoms of its people and provides opportunities for citizens to participate in the political process.

    Content Statements

    • 9. In the United States, people have rights which protect them from undue governmental interference. Rights carry responsibilities which help define how people use their rights and which require respect for the rights of others.
    • 10. Historically, the United States has struggled with majority rule and the extension of minority rights. As a result of this struggle, the government has increasingly extended civil rights to marginalized groups and broadened opportunities for participation.
  • Topic: Ohio’s State and Local Governments

    The State of Ohio acts within the framework of the U.S. Constitution and extends powers and functions to local governments.

    Content Statements

    • 11. As a framework for the state, the Ohio Constitution complements the federal structure of government in the United States.
    • 12. Individuals in Ohio have a responsibility to assist state and local governments as they address relevant and often controversial problems that directly affect their communities.
  • Topic: Public Policy

    Federal, state and local governments address problems and issues by making decisions, creating laws, enforcing regulations and taking action.

    Content Statements

    • 13. A variety of entities within the three branches of government, at all levels, address public policy issues which arise in domestic and international affairs.
    • 14. Individuals and organizations play a role within federal, state and local governments in helping to determine public (domestic and foreign) policy.
  • Topic: Government and the Economy

    The actions of government play a major role in the flow of economic activity. Governments consume and produce goods and services. Fiscal and monetary policies, as well as economic regulations, provide the means for government intervention in the economy.

    Content Statements

    • 15. The federal government uses spending and tax policy to maintain economic stability and foster economic growth. Regulatory actions carry economic costs and benefits.
    • 16. The Federal Reserve System uses monetary tools to regulate the nation’s money supply and moderate the effects of expansion and contraction in the economy.

Modern World History

Theme: This course examines world events from 1600 to the present. It explores the impact of the democratic and industrial revolutions, the forces that led to world domination by European powers, the wars that changed empires, the ideas that led to independence movements and the effects of global interdependence. The concepts of historical thinking introduced in earlier grades continue to build with students locating and analyzing primary and secondary sources from multiple perspectives to draw conclusions.

  • Topic: Historical Thinking and Skills

    Students apply skills by utilizing a variety of resources to construct theses and support or refute contentions made by others. Alternative explanations of historical events are analyzed and questions of historical inevitability are explored.

    Content Statements

    • 1. Historical events provide opportunities to examine alternative courses of action.
    • 2. The use of primary and secondary sources of information includes an examination of the credibility of each source.
    • 3. Historians develop theses and use evidence to support or refute positions.
    • 4. Historians analyze cause, effect, sequence, and correlation in historical events, including multiple causation and long- and short-term causal relations.
  • Topic: Age of Enlightenment (1600-1800)

    The Age of Enlightenment developed from the Scientific Revolution of the 16th and 17th centuries. A new focus on reasoning was used to understand social, political and economic institutions.

    Content Statements

    • 5. The Scientific Revolution impacted religious, political, and cultural institutions by challenging how people viewed the world.
    • 6. Enlightenment thinkers applied reason to discover natural laws guiding human nature in social, political and economic systems and institutions.
    • 7. Enlightenment ideas challenged practices related to religious authority, absolute rule and mercantilism.
  • Topic: Age of Revolutions (1750-1914)

    The Age of Revolutions was a period of two world-encompassing and interrelated developments: the democratic revolution and the industrial revolution. Both had political, economic and social consequences on a global scale.

    Content Statements

    • 8. Enlightenment ideas on the relationship of the individual and the government influenced the American Revolution, French Revolution and Latin American wars for independence.
    • 9. Industrialization had social, political and economic effects on Western Europe and the world.
  • Topic: Imperialism (1800-1914)

    The industrialized nations embarked upon a competition for overseas empires that had profound implications for the entire world. This “new imperialism” focused on the underdeveloped world and led to the domination and exploitation of Asia, Africa and Latin America.

    Content Statements

    • 10. Imperial expansion had political, economic and social roots.
    • 11. Imperialism involved land acquisition, extraction of raw materials, spread of Western
      values and direct political control.
    • 12. The consequences of imperialism were viewed differently by the colonizers and the
      colonized.
  • Topic: Achievements and Crises (1900-1945)

    The first half of the 20th century was one of rapid technological advances. It was a period when the tensions between industrialized nations resulted in World War I and set the stage for World War II. While World War II transformed the balance of world power, it was the most destructive and costly war in terms of human casualties and material resources expended.

    Content Statements

    • 13. Advances in technology, communication and transportation improved lives, but also had negative consequences.
    • 14. The causes of World War I included militarism, imperialism, nationalism and alliances.
    • 15. The consequences of World War I and the worldwide depression set the stage for the Russian Revolution, the rise of totalitarianism, aggressive Axis expansion and the policy of appeasement which in turn led to World War II.
    • 16. Oppression and discrimination resulted in the Armenian Genocide during World War I and the Holocaust, the state-sponsored mass murder of Jews and other groups, during World War II.
    • 17. World War II devastated most of Europe and Asia, led to the occupation of Eastern Europe and Japan, and began the atomic age.
  • Topic: The Cold War (1945-1991)

    Conflicting political and economic ideologies after World War II resulted in the Cold War. The Cold War overlapped with the era of decolonization and national liberation.

    Content Statements

    • 18. The United States and the Soviet Union became superpowers and competed for global influence.
    • 19. Treaties and agreements at the end of World War II changed national boundaries and created multinational organizations.
    • 20. Religious diversity, the end of colonial rule and rising nationalism have led to regional conflicts in the Middle East.
    • 21. Postwar global politics led to the rise of nationalist movements in Africa and Southeast Asia.
    • 22. Political and social struggles have resulted in expanded rights and freedoms for women and indigenous peoples.
  • Topic: Globalization (1991-Present)

    The global balance of power shifted with the end of the Cold War. Wars, territorial disputes, ethnic and cultural conflicts, acts of terrorism, advances in technology, expansion of human rights, and changes in the global economy present new challenges.

    Content Statements

    • 23. The break-up of the Soviet Union ended the Cold War and created challenges for its former allies, the former Soviet republics, Europe, the United States and the non- aligned world.
    • 24. Regional and ethnic conflicts in the post-Cold War era have resulted in acts of terrorism, genocide and ethnic cleansing.
    • 25. Political and cultural groups have struggled to achieve self-governance and self- determination.
    • 26. Emerging economic powers and improvements in technology have created a more interdependent global economy.
    • 27. Proliferation of nuclear weapons has created a challenge to world peace.
    • 28. The rapid increase of global population, coupled with an increase in life expectancy
      and mass migrations have created societal and governmental challenges.
    • 29. Environmental concerns, impacted by population growth and heightened by international competition for the world’s energy supplies, have resulted in a new environmental consciousness and a movement for the sustainability of the world’s resources.

Economics and Financial Literacy

Theme: This course explores the fundamentals that guide individuals and nations as they make choices about how to use limited resources to satisfy their wants. More specifically, it examines the ability of individuals to use knowledge and skills to manage limited financial resources effectively for a lifetime of financial security.

  • Topic: Economic Decision Making and Skills

    Economic decision making relies on the analysis of data. Economists use data to explain trends and decide among economic alternatives. Individuals use data to determine the condition of their finances and to make savings and investment decisions.

    Content Statements

    • 1. Economists analyze multiple sources of data to predict trends, make inferences and arrive at conclusions.
    • 2. Reading financial reports (bank statements, stock market reports, mutual fund statements) enables individuals to make and analyze decisions about personal finances.
  • Topic: Fundamentals of Economics

    Productive resources are limited and allocated in a variety of different ways. An efficient way to allocate productive resources is through markets.

    Content Statements

    • 3. People cannot have all the goods and services they want and, as a result, must choose some things and give up others.
    • 4. Different economic systems (traditional, market, command, and mixed) utilize different methods to allocate limited resources.
    • 5. Markets exist when consumers and producers interact. When supply or demand changes, market prices adjust. Those adjustments send signals and provide incentives to consumers and producers to change their own decisions.
    • 6. Competition among sellers lowers costs and prices, and encourages producers to produce more of what consumers are willing and able to buy. Competition among buyers increases prices and allocates goods and services to those people who are willing and able to pay the most for them.
  • Topic: Government and the Economy

    The health of a nation’s economy is influenced by governmental policy. Fiscal policy can be used to spur economic growth. Monetary policy can be used to moderate fluctuations in the business cycle.

    Content Statements

    • 7. A nation’s overall level of economic well-being is determined by the interaction of spending and production decisions made by all households, firms, government agencies and others in the economy. Economic well-being can be assessed by analyzing economic indicators gathered by the government.
    • 8. Economic policy decisions made by governments result in both intended and unintended consequences.
  • Topic: Global Economy

    Global issues and events influence economic activities.

    Content Statements

    • 9. When regions and nations use comparative advantage to produce at the lowest cost and then trade with others, production, consumption and interdependence increase.
    • 10. Government actions, such as tariffs, quotas, subsidies, trade agreements and membership in multinational economic organizations, significantly impact international trade.
  • Topic: Working and Earning

    Employment provides a means of creating personal income.

    Content Statements

    • 11. Income is determined by many factors including individual skills and abilities, work ethic and market conditions.
    • 12. Employee earning statements include information about gross wages, benefits, taxes and other deductions.
  • Topic: Financial Responsibility and Money Management

    Responsible personal finance decisions are based upon reliable information and used to reach personal goals.

    Content Statements

    • 13. Financial decision-making involves considering alternatives by examining costs and benefits.
    • 14. A personal financial plan includes financial goals and a budget, including spending on goods and services, savings and investments, insurance and philanthropy.
    • 15. Different payment methods have advantages and disadvantages.
  • Topic: Saving and Investing

    Saving and investing strategies help individuals achieve personal financial goals.

    Content Statements

    • 16. Saving and investing help to build wealth.
    • 17. Savings can serve as a buffer against economic hardship.
    • 18. Different costs and benefits are associated with saving and investing alternatives.
    • 19. Banks, brokerages and insurance companies provide access to investments such as certificates of deposit, stocks, bonds and mutual funds.
  • Topic: Credit and Debt

    Credit and debt can be used to achieve personal financial goals.

    Content Statements

    • 20. There are costs and benefits associated with various sources of credit available from different types of financial institutions.
    • 21. Credit and debt can be managed to maintain credit worthiness.
    • 22. Consumer protection laws provide financial safeguards.
  • Topic: Risk Management

    There are various strategies to help protect personal assets and wealth.

    Content Statements

    • 23. Property and liability insurance protect against risks associated with use of property.
    • 24. Health, disability and life insurance protect against risks associated with increased expenses and loss of income.
    • 25. Steps can be taken to safeguard one’s personal financial information and reduce the risk of loss.

Contemporary World Issues

The dynamics of global interactions among nations and regions present issues that affect all humanity. These dynamics include: competing beliefs and goals; methods of engagement; and conflict and cooperation. Contemporary issues have political, economic, social, historic and geographic components. Approaches to addressing global and regional issues reflect historical influences and multiple perspectives. Students can impact global issues through service learning and senior projects.

  • Topic: Global Connections

    The 21st century is characterized by changing circumstances as new economies emerge and new technologies change the way people interact. Issues related to health, economics, security and the environment are universal.

    Content Statements

    • 1. Trade, alliances, treaties and international organizations contribute to the increasing interconnectedness of nations and peoples in the 21st century.
    • 2. Advances in communications technology have profound effects on the ability of governments, interest groups, individuals and the media to share information across national and cultural borders.
  • Topic: Civic Participation and Skills

    Individuals and groups have the capacity to engage with others to impact global issues.

    Content Statements

    • 3. Individuals can evaluate media messages that are constructed using particular tools, characteristics and conventions for unique purposes. Different communication methods affect how people define and act on issues.
    • 4. Individuals can assess how effective communicators address diverse audiences.
    • 5. Individuals can identify, assess and evaluate world events, engage in deliberative civil debate and influence public processes to address global issues.
    • 6. Effective civic participation involves identifying problems or dilemmas, proposing appropriate solutions, formulating action plans, and assessing the positive and negative results of actions taken.
    • 7. Individuals can participate through non-governmental organizations to help address humanitarian needs.
  • Topic: Civil and Human Rights

    There are challenges to civil rights and human rights throughout the world. Politics, economics and culture can all influence perceptions of civil and human rights.

    • 8. Beliefs about civil and human rights vary among social and governmental systems.
    • 9. Nations and international organizations pursue their own interests on issues related to civil and human rights, resulting in both conflict and cooperation particularly as it relates to injustices against minority groups.
    • 10. Modern instances of genocide and ethnic cleansing present individual, organizational and national issues related to the responsibilities of participants and non-participants.
  • Topic: Sustainability

    An increasingly global society is faced with the interdependency of ecological, social and economic systems. The functioning of these systems determines the sustainability of natural and human communities at local, regional, national and global levels.

    Content Statements

    • 11. Decisions about human activities made by individuals and societies have implications for both current and future generations, including intended and unintended consequences.
    • 12. Sustainability issues are interpreted and treated differently by people viewing them from various political, economic and cultural perspectives.
    • 13. International associations and nongovernmental organizations offer means of collaboration to address sustainability issues on local, national and international levels.
  • Topic: Technology

    Technological advances present issues related to costs, distribution of benefits, ethical considerations, and intended and unintended consequences.

    Content Statements

    • 14. The development and use of technology influences economic, political, ethical and social issues.
    • 15. Technologies inevitably involve trade-offs between costs and benefits. Decisions about the use of products and systems can result in intended and unintended consequences.
  • Topic: National Security and International Diplomacy

    The political, economic and social goals of nations, international associations and nongovernmental organizations may be incompatible with each other and lead to conflicts.

    Content Statements

    • 16. Nations seek to ensure the security of their geographic territories, political institutions, economic systems and ways of life. Maintaining security has political, social and economic costs.
    • 17. Economic, political and social differences between global entities can lead to conflict unless mitigated through diplomacy or cooperative efforts.
    • 18. Individuals and organizations work within, or outside of, established systems of power, authority and governance to influence their own security and the security of others.
  • Topic: The Global Economy

    The global economy is an international marketplace fueled by competition, trade and integration.

    • 19. The global economy creates advantages and disadvantages for different segments of the world’s population.
    • 20. Trade agreements, multinational organizations, embargoes and protectionism impact markets.
    • 21. The distribution of wealth and economic power among countries changes over time.
    • 22. The global economy creates interdependence so that economic circumstances in one country impact events in other countries.

World Geography

Theme: This course builds on students’ understanding of geography and spatial thinking. Contemporary issues are explored through the lens of geography. In addition to understanding where physical and cultural features are located and why those features are located as they are, students examine the implications of these spatial arrangements.

  • Topic: Spatial Thinking and Skills

    The ability to use geographic tools to locate data spatially enables people to gain a better understanding of contemporary issues. Investigations of spatial information provide guidance in solving global problems.

    Content Statements

    • 1. Properties and functions of geographic representations (e.g., maps, globes, graphs, diagrams, Internet-based mapping applications, geographic information systems, global positioning systems, remote sensing, and geographic visualizations) affect how they can be used to represent, analyze and interpret geographic patterns and processes.
    • 2. Geographic representations and geospatial technologies are used to investigate, analyze and communicate the results of geographic problem solving.
  • Topic: Environment and Society

    Humans adapt to and modify the environment and shape the landscape through their interaction with the land. This has both positive and negative effects on the environment.

    Content Statements

    • 3. Human modifications of the physical environment in one place often lead to changes in other places (e.g., construction of a dam provides downstream flood control, construction of a city by-pass reduces commercial activity in the city center, implementation of dry farming techniques in a region leads to new transportation links and hubs).
    • 4. Human societies use a variety of strategies to adapt to the opportunities and constraints presented by the physical environment (e.g., farming in flood plains and terraced farming, building hydroelectric plants by waterfalls and constructing hydroelectric dams, using solar panels as heat source and using extra insulation to retain heat).
    • 5. Physical processes influence the formation and distribution of renewable, nonrenewable, and flow resources (e.g., tectonic activity plays a role in the formation and location of fossil fuels, erosion plays a role in the formation of sedimentary rocks, rainfall patterns affect regional drainage patterns).
    • 6. There are costs and benefits of using renewable, nonrenewable, and flow resources (e.g., availability, sustainability, environmental impact, expense).
    • 7. Human interaction with the environment is affected by cultural characteristics (e.g., plowing with oxen or with tractors, development of water resources for industry or recreation, resource conservation or development).
  • Topic: Movement

    People interact with other people, places, and things every day of their lives. They travel from one place to another; they communicate with each other; and they rely upon products, information, and ideas that come from beyond their immediate environment.

    Content Statements

    • 8. Physical, cultural, economic, and political factors contribute to human migrations (e.g., drought, religious conflicts, job opportunities, immigration laws).
    • 9. Human migrations impact physical and human systems (e.g., stress on food supplies in refugee camps, removal of natural obstacles to movement, harvest productivity and migrant labor, calls for an official language in countries with high immigration, reduction in city tax revenues due to urban emigration).
    • 10. Activities and patterns of trade and communication create interdependence among countries in different regions (e.g., seed corn grown in Iowa and planted in South America, high-definition televisions manufactured in Japan and viewed in the United States, news outlets from many countries available around the world via the Internet, instant access to data affects stock markets in different countries).
  • Topic: Region

    A region is an area on the earth’s surface that is defined by certain unifying characteristics which give it a measure of homogeneity and distinguish it from surrounding areas. The unifying characteristics may be physical or cultural. Regions change over time.

    Content Statements

    • 11. Criteria are used to organize regions and as the criteria change, the identified regions change (e.g., types of economic activities, ethnic groups, natural vegetation).
    • 12. The characteristics of regions change over time and there are consequences related to those changes (e.g., industrial belt to rust belt, pristine locations to tourist attractions, colony to independent state).
    • 13. There are interconnections within and among physical and human regions (e.g., river systems, transportation linkages, common currency).
    • 14. Regions are used as a basis to analyze global geographic issues (e.g., desertification, political disputes, economic unions).
  • Topic: Human Settlement

    People live in settlements which vary in size, composition, location, arrangement, and function. These settlements are the focus of most aspects of human life including economic activities, transportation systems, governance, communications and culture. Human settlements differ between regions, places and over time.

    Content Statements

    • 15. Patterns of settlement change over time in terms of functions, sizes, and spatial patterns (e.g., a canal town becomes an industrial city, a rural area becomes a transportation hub, cities merge into a megalopolis).
    • 16. Urbanization provides opportunities and challenges for physical and human systems in cities and their surrounding regions (e.g., development of suburbs, loss of habitat, central markets, squatter settlements on city outskirts, regional specialization in services or products, creation of ethnic enclaves).
  • Topic: Globalization

    The modern world is said to be “shrinking” or “flattening” through the processes of globalization. The scale and speed of global interactions continue to increase in fields such as technology, markets, information sharing and telecommunication. Globalization has impacted human-environmental interactions, has affected the movement of people, products and ideas, and has implications for what constitutes a region and connections among existing regions.

    Content Statements

    • 17. Globalization has shaped new cultural, economic, and political ideas and entities (e.g., universal human rights, European Union, terrorist networks).
    • 18. Globalization has cultural, economic, physical and political consequences (e.g., Internet access increases availability of information, outsourcing leads to regional unemployment, development of infrastructure impacts local ecosystems and economies, computer hacking into sensitive data bases leads to insecurity).
    • 19. Global trade and communication systems reduce the effect of time on the distribution of goods, services, and information (e.g., reliance on local foods versus global trade in perishable foods, online brokering versus personal brokers, Internet access versus library access).

Alabama: 9th-Grade Standards

Article Body

AL.9 Standard: World History—1500 to the Present

At the ninth-grade level, students continue the study of world history from 1500 to the present. Through historical inquiry, students gain an understanding and appreciation of history as a story of people much like themselves and become increasingly able to understand global interdependence and connections among world societies.

9.1

  • 9.1. Students will:

    Describe developments in Italy and Northern Europe during the Renaissance period with respect to humanism, arts and literature, intellectual development, increased trade, and advances in technology.(History)

9.2

  • 9.2.1 Students will:

    Describe the role of mercantilism and imperialism in European exploration and colonization in the sixteenth century, including the Columbian Exchange. (Economics, Geography, History, Civics and Government)

  • 9.2.2 Students will practice:

    • Describing the impact of the Commercial Revolution on European society
    • Identifying major ocean currents, wind patterns, landforms, and climates affecting European exploration
      • Grade Level Example:

        marking ocean currents and wind patterns on a map

9.3

  • 9.3. Students will:

    Explain causes of the Reformation and its impact, including tensions between religious and secular authorities, reformers and doctrines, the Counter-Reformation, the English Reformation, and wars of religion. (History)

9.4

  • 9.4.1 Students will:

    Explain the relationship between physical geography and cultural development in India, Africa, Japan, and China in the early Global Age, including trade and travel, natural resources, and movement and isolation of peoples and ideas. (Economics, Geography, History)

  • 9.4.2 Students will practice:

    • Depicting the general location of, size of, and distance between regions in the early Global Age
      • Grade Level Example:

        drawing sketch maps

9.5

  • 9.5.1 Students will:

    Describe the rise of absolutism and constitutionalism and their impact on European nations. (Civics and Government)

  • 9.5.2 Students will practice:

    • Contrasting philosophies of Thomas Hobbes and John Locke and the belief in the divine right of kings
    • Comparing absolutism as it developed in France, Russia, and Prussia, including the reigns of Louis XIV, Peter the Great, and Frederick the Great
    • Identifying major provisions of the Petition of Rights and the English Bill of Rights

9.6

  • 9.6. Students will:

    Identify significant ideas and achievements of scientists and philosophers of the Scientific Revolution and the Age of Enlightenment. (History)

    • Grade Level Example:

      Scientific Revolution—astronomical theories of Copernicus and Galileo, Newton’s law of gravity
      Age of Enlightenment—philosophies of Montesquieu, Voltaire, and Rousseau

9.7

  • 9.7.1 Students will:

    Describe the impact of the French Revolution on Europe, including political evolution, social evolution, and diffusion of nationalism and liberalism. (Geography, History, Civics and Government)

  • 9.7.2 Students will practice:

    • Identifying causes of the French Revolution
    • Describing the influence of the American Revolution upon the French Revolution
    • Identifying objectives of different groups participating in the French Revolution
    • Describing the role of Napoleon as an empire builder

9.8

  • 9.8. Students will:

    Compare revolutions in Latin America and the Caribbean, including Haiti, Colombia, Venezuela, Argentina, Chile, and Mexico. (Geography, History, Civics and Government)

    • Grade Level Example:

      Identifying the location of countries in Latin America

9.9

  • 9.9.1 Students will:

    Describe the impact of technological inventions, conditions of labor, and the economic theories of capitalism, liberalism, socialism, and Marxism during the Industrial Revolution on the economics, society, and politics of Europe. (Economics, History, Civics and Government)

  • 9.9.2 Students will practice:

    • Identifying important inventors in Europe during the Industrial Revolution
    • Comparing the Industrial Revolution in England with later revolutions in Europe

9.10

  • 9.10.1 Students will:

    Describe the influence of urbanization during the nineteenth century on the Western World. (Geography, History, Civics and Government)

    • Grade Level Example:

      interaction with the environment, provisions for public health, increased opportunities for upward mobility, changes in social stratification, development of Romanticism and Realism, development of Impressionism and Cubism

  • 9.10.2 Students will practice:

    • Describing the search for political democracy and social justice in the Western World
      • Grade Level Example:

        European Revolution of 1848, slavery and emancipation in the United States, emancipation of serfs in Russia, universal manhood suffrage, women’s suffrage

9.11

  • 9.11.1. Students will:

    Describe the impact of European nationalism and Western imperialism as forces of global transformation, including the unification of Italy and Germany, the rise of Japan’s power in East Asia, economic roots of imperialism, imperialist ideology, colonialism and national rivalries, and United States imperialism. (Economics, History, Civics and Government)

  • 9.11.2 Students will practice:

    • Describing resistance to European imperialism in Africa, Japan, and China

9.12

  • 9.12.1 Students will:

    Explain causes and consequences of World War I, including imperialism, militarism, nationalism, and the alliance system. (Geography, History, Civics and Government)

  • 9.12.2 Students will practice:

    • Describing the rise of Communism in Russia during World War I
      • Grade Level Example:

        return of Vladimir Lenin, rise of Bolsheviks

    • Describing military technology used during World War I
    • Identifying problems created by the Treaty of Versailles of 1919
      • Grade Level Example:

        Germany’s reparations and war guilt, international controversy over the League of Nations

    • Identifying alliances during World War I and boundary changes after World War I

9.13

  • 9.13.1 Students will:

    Explain challenges of the post-World War I period. (Economics, History, Civics and Government)

    • Grade Level Example:

      1920s cultural disillusionment, colonial rebellion and turmoil in Ireland and India, attempts to achieve political stability in Europe

  • 9.13.2 Students will practice:

    • Identifying causes of the Great Depression
    • Characterizing the global impact of the Great Depression

9.14

  • 9.14.1 Students will:

    Describe causes and consequences of World War II. (Geography, History, Civics and Government)

    • Grade Level Example:

      causes—unanswered aggression, Axis goal of world conquest
      consequences—changes in political boundaries; Allied goals; lasting issues such as the Holocaust, Atomic Age, and Nuremberg Trials

  • 9.14.2 Students will practice:

    • Explaining the rise of militarist and totalitarian states in Italy, Germany, the Soviet Union, and Japan
    • Identifying turning points of World War II in the European and Pacific Theaters
    • Depicting geographic locations of world events between 1939 and 1945
    • Identifying on a map changes in national borders as a result of World War II

9.15

  • 9.15.1 Students will:

    Describe post-World War II realignment and reconstruction in Europe, Asia, and Latin America, including the end of colonial empires. (History, Civics and Government)

    • Grade Level Example:

      reconstruction of Japan; nationalism in India, Pakistan, Indonesia, and Africa; Chinese Communist Revolution; creation of Jewish state of Israel; Cuban Revolution; Central American conflicts

  • 9.15.2 Students will practice:

    • Explaining origins of the Cold War
      • Grade Level Example:

        Yalta and Potsdam Conferences, ―Iron Curtain,‖ Truman Doctrine, Marshall Plan, United Nations, North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), Warsaw Pact

    • Tracing the progression of the Cold War
      • Grade Level Example:

        nuclear weapons, European power struggles, Korean War, Berlin Wall, Cuban Missile Crisis, Vietnam War

9.16

  • 9.16.1 Students will:

    Describe the role of nationalism, militarism, and civil war in today’s world, including the use of terrorism and modern weapons at the close of the twentieth and the beginning of the twenty-first centuries.(Economics, Geography, History, Civics and Government)

  • 9.16.2 Students will practice:

    • Describing the collapse of the Soviet Empire and Russia’s struggle for democracy, free markets, and economic recovery and the roles of Mikhail Gorbachev, Ronald Reagan, and Boris Yeltsin
      • Grade Level Example:

        economic failures, demands for national and human rights, resistance from Eastern Europe, reunification of Germany

    • Describing effects of internal conflict, nationalism, and enmity in South Africa, Northern Ireland, Chile, the Middle East, Somalia and Rwanda, Cambodia, and the Balkans
    • Describing effects of internal conflict, nationalism, and enmity in South Africa, Northern Ireland, Chile, the Middle East, Somalia and Rwanda, Cambodia, and the Balkans
    • Depicting geographic locations of major world events from 1945 to the present

9.17

  • 9.17.1 Students will:

    Describe emerging democracies from the late twentieth century to the present. (Economics, History, Civics and Government)

  • 9.17.2 Students will practice:

    • Discussing problems and opportunities involving science, technology, and the environment in the late twentieth century
      • Grade Level Example:

        genetic engineering, space exploration

    • Identifying problems involving civil liberties and human rights from 1945 to the present and ways they have been addressed
    • Relating economic changes to social changes in countries adopting democratic forms of government

Elizabeth Schaefer on Facebook in the Classroom

Date Published
Image
Photo, Facebook, Jan. 26, 2010, Colevito Mambembe, Flickr
Article Body

Many teenagers spend much of their free time in a virtual world, and the school world can be peripheral to the connections they make through TV or a computer screen. As our society becomes more and more driven by social media, Facebook opens a door to meet students where they are and to create informal educational connections outside of the classroom.

Why did we become history teachers? For me it was because I love exploring this country and its past. I take great joy in visiting museums and historic sites to learn about hidden pieces of our past. I spend time every year experiencing different states and growing my understanding of how geography and regional culture shaped past events and affect politics today.

Unfortunately, all of those verbs—"exploring," "visiting," and "experiencing"—have limitations in the school system, so as teachers we need to look for new and creative tools that are within our reach. Since I began teaching, my students have been on my mind during my adventures, especially those within my own city—Washington, DC. I wish that they could have the experiences that I have, or at least be aware that these experiences exist. It was somewhere along this line of thought that I realized my guilty pleasure, Facebook, could actually be a useful academic tool. I started a project to learn more about Facebook's potential to engage and nurture lifelong historians.

Utilizing Facebook Academically

To preface, this project will be described as an addition to classroom learning. For those John Dewey enthusiasts squeezed out by test prep, Facebook offers an opportunity for your students to explore and engage at will. Rather than mandating participation, the teacher enters the students' world and offers various resources that students may choose to read and interact with. Here are some of the many ways that Facebook can be utilized:

Sharing Visual Aids
My original idea was primarily to utilize Facebook for my visual learners, to help support vocabulary and historic concepts. Images can be found on Google within seconds, but presenting images from your own life provides relevance and tangibility. A smartphone is helpful to upload pictures as you take them and therefore to also model that history is alive and active in your life.

Examples: If we were studying city life during the colonial period and I traveled to Boston, I would upload a photo of a historic building to demonstrate the small windows and brick-laying techniques. As a nature lover in a city school, uploading photos has been especially helpful with geographic terms, such as "marsh" and "plains," that the students are unfamiliar with.

Modeling a Love For History
All of our cities and towns have their own unique history and hidden treasures. While I spend a great deal of time in local parks and museums, my students, like many teenagers, repeatedly tell me that they spend weekends at the movies, sports, or the mall. I do not think this is simply because they are not interested or cannot get to cultural sites, but because it does not occur to them to go. Post a status update saying that you are listening to a presidential address or watching a historical movie. Let them know you are at a museum or just heard a fun fact. Take pictures on a trip when you stumble upon an old cemetery or find a family heirloom. Let the students know when you feel excited about being a history nerd!

Highlighting Current Events
Those less practiced in Facebook may not realize that it can literally be a newsfeed. By clicking to post a "link" instead of "status," you can link your students to any online news source. These could be articles that you think they should all be aware of or articles that may interest a particular group of students.

In addition, any number of politicians, NGOs, and national celebrities have Facebook pages, and this Facebook world is likely not the one that your students pay attention to. If they see that you are "Facebook friends" with Barack Obama and John Boehner, this might prompt them to check both Facebook profiles out and learn more.

Creating Interactive Puzzles
I get the best response when I post interactive puzzles for the students. They can be about anything you are studying or a review throwback to the beginning of the year.

Examples: In the Smithsonian American Art Museum, there is a piece that combines license plates from all 50 states that spell out the words of the Declaration of Independence. I took a quick picture and then posted this up with "Who can tell us what this is?" Several students chimed in.

Questions and puzzles like this can come in many forms, and do not need to relate to museums. For instance, a new movie is coming out called Jumping Over the Broom and I plan to post a link to the movie and ask if anyone remembers the historic significance of this tradition to slave life.

Expanding Student Choices
Most students love activities which involve the computer and social media, and the more we can do to spark interest, the better. There are many ways to use Facebook for turning in assignments or expanding on in-class participation.

Example: When discussing slavery, I asked students what one carries with them when deprived of everything. The students had to go home and look for skills or knowledge that the enslaved could have brought with them across the ocean. They were invited to either bring in items or describe what they had found. As another option, students could post what they found on Facebook. I also posted my own pictures that weekend: a drum, a quilt, and a woven basket to show that the skills brought by the enslaved Africans are seen everywhere.

Giving Shout-Outs and Recognition
Up to this point, you may be able to complete the same goals with a blog—but a unique aspect of Facebook is public recognition. Your teenage students are used to sharing their happiness and sadness and pride across a computer screen so go ahead and jump in! For those wary of causing embarrassment, I recommend sticking to recognizing the whole class. This is fun because it gathers lots of "likes" and revs up the competition.

Building Community
Facebook was designed as an online community and is therefore built to create feelings of belonging. Teachers can share pictures of field trips the students went on, follow along with a topic important to the community, and create special groups relevant to school. Some of my students who are shy in class seem to have a different online personality and are more likely to comment and join in through the computer.

Encouraging a Sense of Ownership and Interest in Our Country
In teaching history, we are passing on ownership of this country, but many students in many cities and towns have not been more than one or two states away. If my Washington, DC students skim pictures of the Oregon coast, Arches National Park, or a New Mexico Indian reservation, my greatest hope would be that the pictures make them want to visit more of our amazing country. Even if they are content where they are, they can at least be more culturally aware and form a broader definition of national diversity.

Ensuring Security and Consent

Securing Privacy
In setting up this project, the first thing to do is to establish a secure Facebook page at www.facebook.com. I recommend the following steps to ensure privacy:

  • Separate this account from any other Facebook account that you have.
  • Add only the information that you are comfortable with. I added my favorite books, some inspirational quotes, and a few historical movies to my profile. In this account, I also chose to include some pictures of myself and my family and created a couple of photo albums with facts about places I had been.
  • Ensure that all of your security settings are set to "Friends Only." This is for the security of the students who "friend" you. It allows only those students who have friended you to have access to your page and your pictures.
  • If you do have a personal Facebook account, I recommend double checking that your settings on it are secure before going online with your teacher account. I temporarily switched my personal profile picture to a landscape so that if the students were searching for me, they would select and friend my teacher account, which had a photo of me as the profile picture.

Ensuring Consent
Before just "friending" all of your students, there are a couple necessary steps to take. First, I sought approval from the principal and then I sent a letter home for all of the parents. The parents had to sign the permission slip before any online contact could be established. In this letter, I welcomed the families to join my community on Facebook if they were uncomfortable with their children doing so. Within this letter, I included an additional item about whether I could post pictures of the kids on Facebook. Most parents who agreed to let their children participate in the project agreed to let them participate in all of its aspects.

Project Challenges

Facebook has so much potential for being an educational tool, but I cannot claim I have had full success quite yet. I plan to continue experimenting until this initiative matches the vision that I have for it. Here are some of the challenges I faced.

Encouraging Buy-In
Once everything was set up, then I needed to hook my students. If they did not want to join in, everything was for naught. To present the project to them, I emphasized the "shout-out" portion of the activity and told them that I would offer some project options only on Facebook. I only received about a 40% opt-in rate. On the plus side, the kids who participated were probably the most likely to actually search out the educational articles and pictures that I posted. Next year, I plan to start this project with the beginning of the year paperwork to see if that increases participation.

Creating Routine
It was very difficult for me to create a routine that involved regularly updating my student Facebook account. Facebook is justifiably blocked on my school network so this always had to be an outside-of-work project. Everything I did for the project therefore felt like extra. Next year, I plan to start from the beginning with a commitment to posting biweekly to create more of a routine for myself and the students.

Maintaining Distance
I recommend avoiding skimming your students' pages. There is just information out there that we do not want to know. I requested from the students and in the parent letter that students only allow me access to their Limited Profile, a setting that does not allow me full access to the students' conversations.

Also, be aware that commenting on your students' status may be seen as invasive. I have commented now and then when it was relevant specifically to school or current issues involving social studies or social justice. In my opinion, especially early in the year, teachers may be better off viewing Facebook interaction as one-way.

Facing the Inequity of Computers
Utilizing media outside of the classroom involves inevitable inequities. Since Facebook is blocked at most schools and some students cannot leisurely browse the Internet at home, this project does give some students an unfair advantage. I have not found a way to work around this.

Starting Your Own Projects

I hope that other teachers experiment with this online tool, and would love to hear about any successes or receive feedback. For the first time in history, teachers can reach their students during the after-school at-home hours to build community, provide historic resources, and truly offer the type of engagement that allows us teachers to declare ourselves lifelong learners.

For more information

Get more ideas on using social media with your students in Digital Classroom. You can read more about Facebook, or watch an example of how one teacher used it to engage her students in the lives of historical figures.

Confronting the "Official Story" of American History

Image
"Washington Crossing the Deleware". Emanuel Gottlieb Leutze. 1851 oil on canvas
Article Body

Keith Barton of Indiana University and Linda Levstik of the University of Kentucky wanted to understand the "official" story of American history so often presented in classrooms and textbooks. What happens to aspects of history that don’t fit the way we usually teach U.S. history? And how do students respond?

Barton and Levstik interviewed 48 children, grades 5–8, to see how middle-schoolers understand the significance of particular events. Students were asked to choose from a number of historical events in order to determine which eight to include on a timeline of the last 500 years.

Many students alighted on a central theme in U.S. history: steadily expanding rights and opportunities. While stories like this help structure students' thinking about American history, traditional themes (such as perpetual progress or expanding freedoms) left them ill-equipped to deal with issues like racial inequality or political dissent.

While stories . . . help structure students' thinking about American history, traditional themes . . . left them ill-equipped to deal with issues like racial inequality or political dissent.

This study suggests that middle-grade students may need help grasping the complexities of the past or finding a place for stories that don’t fit common narratives. The authors proposed that teachers expose students to more complex and diverse perspectives by identifying what such narratives leave out. How has progress not been achieved? Where have freedoms not been expanded? What are the exceptions, the outliers, the cases that don’t fit? The researchers believe that students can learn traditional thematic narratives, while at the same time exploring the richness and complexity of history.

Thematic Trends

When Barton and Levstik interviewed the students, they found a core group of themes emerged from the events students chose as the most significant. Stories of national origin, American exceptionality, expanding freedoms, and technological progress consistently appeared among the students' choices. Such themes represented an "official version" of American history that all students seemed to recognize.

Alternative Stories

Some students viewed events as important despite the fact that their themes did not easily fit into the more popular narratives. Racism and sexism directly contradict themes of progress and expanding freedoms. Other events like the Great Depression and the Vietnam War fly in the face of American exceptionality. In both cases, however, students found it challenging to explain why they found these events significant. While students were convinced of the importance of such events, they struggled to reconcile them with common themes of U.S. history.

Two Ideas in Their Minds

American history presents a wide variety of events and themes. Some, like our nation’s heritage regarding race, class, and gender, pose particular challenges. Accustomed to justifying the importance of events by referencing a few common themes, many students find themselves at a loss when confronted by events they know are important, but which don’t seem to fit the stories they are used to hearing. Lacking an overarching framework to help make sense of such events, they develop overly simplistic explanations to reconcile jarring events with the official story. As the sample application below shows, their explanations may put events together, but at the expense of historical accuracy.

image
Photomechanical print, Progress, Keppler & Schwarzmann, c. 1901, LoC
In the Classroom
  • Have students create a timeline of important events in American history, asking them to explain why they make particular choices.
  • After students create their timeline, discuss the major themes that arise from their picks. Do they seem to represent an "official" history?
  • Once they have identified common historical themes, ask students to pick out events that don’t fit the "official story." What might explain this lack of fit?
Sample Application

When learning about the Great Depression, one group of students demonstrated a characteristic dilemma. As far as they knew, throughout its history the United States had been on a steady march of economic progress. Consequently, students weren't sure how the Great Depression fit into this story:

  • "It wasn't a good part of history."
  • "It was something to learn from."
  • "It was the first time our country had become really poor."
  • "They realized that they weren’t the god of all countries."
  • "It’s not going to be perfect all the time."

As these quotes demonstrate, students had accumulated a wide range of conceptions about the Great Depression. They knew bad things had happened, but thought these occurred uniformly to all Americans. As a result, they concluded that the nation had been punished for being too prosperous or self-satisfied. They entirely missed the fact that the Great Depression occurred for many specific and complex reasons, and affected different Americans in dramatically diverse ways.

Bibliography

Keith C. Barton and Linda S. Levstik, "'It Wasn’t a Good Part of History': National Identity and Students' Explanations of Historical Significance," Teachers College Record 99, no. 3 (Spring 1998): 478–513.

Intertextual Reading of Two Primary Documents

Image
Daguerreotype, unidentified African American woman, c. 1850, Flickr Commons
Article Body

This student think-aloud shows a 99-second video of a student reading a Social Security poster and congressional testimony by a NAACP representative. The student reads the poster out loud, generating a question as she reads. Rather than spending time hypothesizing answers, the student reads the next document, which helps her answer her original question, and raises other questions about the significance of race and class in the fashioning of Social Security legislation.

This example of intertextual reading reveals a student capable of reading documents using and comparing multiple documents to help her answer historical questions. The accompanying text commentary explains what the student is doing and how teachers can support students in intertextual reading. The documents she interprets may be downloaded here.

Close Reading for Vocabulary, Context, and Tone

Article Body

This student think-aloud shows a high school student reading a New York Times article about the Scopes Trial and working to make sense of its meaning. During this 74-second video, she identifies words she is unfamiliar with and draws on outside information in order to analyze the tone of the document. As a result of this close reading, she is able to better understand not only the meaning of the document, but also the viewpoint of its author—a big city reporter visiting a small town in Tennessee. A commentary on the think-aloud is also available and you can find the document the student reads here.

Reading for Context

Article Body

This video shows a student thinking-aloud while reading a headnote to an excerpt from Bayard Rustin's diary. In this 58-second reading, the student puzzles through the motives of civil rights leaders, who were concerned that Rustin—a gay Communist—would undermine the movement. He identifies the importance of context in his reading, noting that "this was during a great fear of Communists in America" and that if the movement was aligned with Communists, "it would lose a lot of support." The accompanying written commentary highlights the importance of contextualization, which the student uses to better understand a world in which civil rights activists would exclude someone who was different. Find the document the student reads here.

Stories in History: Is Narrative an American Approach?

Image
An eigth grade teacher reading a childrens book to her class. NHEC
Article Body

In "A Sociocultural Perspective on Children’s Understanding of Historical Change: Comparative Findings From Northern Ireland and the United States," Keith Barton, a professor at Indiana University, looked at how children in different countries learn history, specifically the role played by narrative.

Barton observed that American students learn the "story" of American history, more often than not, as one of perpetual progress. In Northern Ireland, history is seen as relationships among social institutions over time, not a story about progress.

Barton wondered about the effects of such an approach. To that end he interviewed 121 students, ages 6–12, in four schools across Northern Ireland, asking how and why life had changed over time. Along with classroom observations and collecting data from history-related settings like museums, Barton’s interviews demonstrated how students in a non-American cultural context learn about history.

When he compared these to studies done in the United States, Barton found that American students portray historical change as straightforward, linear, and generally beneficial progress, while the Irish students saw history as either random and ambiguous, or cyclical. The American students studied tended to focus on accomplishments of historical figures, whereas students in Northern Ireland often discussed the role of societal and economic forces.

Narrative in American History

The "story" of history taught to American students frequently takes the form of a "quest-for-freedom" narrative in which life slowly but surely gets better for all Americans. This serves to unite a diverse society, such as is found in the U.S. By contrast, in Northern Ireland, where Protestants and Catholics remain divided, the narrative form creates the potential for opposing sides to take aim at each other. Consequently, in Northern Ireland, the primary emphasis in history is on societal relationships—relationships between different groups, as well as between people and institutions.

The "story" of history taught to American students frequently takes the form of a "quest-for-freedom" narrative in which life slowly but surely gets better for all Americans. This serves to unite a diverse society, such as is found in the U.S.
The Individual in American History

History classes in the United States also tend to focus more on the role of exceptional individuals in driving history forward. In this version of history prominent figures initiate a series of events which follow a causal chain to bring about significant change. For example, the American students learned that the civil rights movement was the product of Martin Luther King, Jr.’s genius rather than a broad range of social and institutional forces. In Northern Ireland, the students focused less on individuals and more on issues relating to social and economic structures. Barton suggests this may be because Americans are more comfortable dealing with individuals and their stories than with issues such as social class and prejudice. Conversely, there are few historical figures taught in Northern Ireland classrooms who don't represent a political position of one kind or another. Thus, while the Northern Irish are comfortable discussing social class, for instance, they have less experience examining the influence of particular individuals.

Progress in American History

Barton's study showed that narratives about American history are frequently positive stories about the triumph of progress: as time passes, technology improves, freedoms expand, and life gets better. In Northern Ireland, stories about progress are much less common. Time goes on and life changes, but they do so in unpredictable ways. Barton argues that while a focus on progress may be positive, giving students a feeling of shared identity and inspiring their belief that Americans can learn from their mistakes, relying solely on such a narrative doesn't acquaint students with the effects of societal forces on individual actions or the diversity that exists at any given time in history.

image
Poster, Forging Ahead, Harry Herzog, 1936-1941, Library of Congress
In the Classroom

Help students understand that the passage of time doesn't always bring what is commonly viewed as "progress."

  • Begin with contrasting images—a rural village and a large city—and ask students to explain the relationship between the two.
  • Students will likely explain how the village became the city. This is a good jumping-off point to helping them see that the "story of history" is not always simple or straightforward.
  • Next, explain that villages and cities have often existed simultaneously.
  • Spend some time discussing why and how cities first began to emerge. While urban centers may look like signs of "progress," students should be made aware that there is a more complex relationship between villages and cities.
  • Suggest to students that historical development doesn't occur in a simple progressive sequence, and that historical periods can't be boiled down to a single image. While many people in the past lived in villages, there are also cities that date back thousands of years. And even though today many people reside in cities, villages are far from extinct.
Sample Application

In interviewing students in Northern Ireland, Barton gave them a number of exercises. One asked the students to explain why British students were once caned—hit with a reed or branch—by their teachers, and why the practice ceased. In answering, one third of the students attributed the change to inevitable progress:

Because over time they realized that they should be less strict.

They just found out that it’s really, really bad, and they’re thinking of other people’s feelings now.

In explaining how things change, these students didn't mention collective action or how institutional change can bring about social improvements. However, the rest of the students—two-thirds of those interviewed by Barton—pointed to changing social relations, collective action like strikes and protests, and evolving legal and government institutions:

Because if you cane them, you could get sent to jail. . . it’s against the law to hurt somebody that you don’t know.

New people came in. . . and they made new rules like child abuse, like jails, and all that kind of thing.

For these students, caning ended not because of inevitable progress, or even due to a change in attitude; instead, the changing attitudes themselves led to collective action, that in turn produced new laws and regulations.

Bibliography

Keith Barton, "A Sociocultural Perspective on Children’s Understanding of Historical Change: Comparative Findings From Northern Ireland and the United States," American Educational Research Journal 38, no. 4 (Winter 2001), 881-913.

Amy Trenkle's Be the Blogger!

Date Published
Image
Blog, Lincoln Logs, http://stampslincoln.blogspot.com/, Amy Trenkle
Blog, Lincoln Logs, http://stampslincoln.blogspot.com/, Amy Trenkle
Article Body
Beginning to Blog

During the 2008–2009 school year, in an effort to integrate more technology into my classroom I started blogging with my students about history class. Because I was pretty new to blogging and wasn’t sure how it would go, I did one collective site for the 8th grade. Basically, the students wrote and I uploaded it to the blog. As the year went on, I logged in for students and they took over the maintenance of the site. Sometimes the writing was an assignment and I chose the best ones to post. Other times, I offered extra credit if they posted about a topic provided. And still other times I loved what a student wrote and typed it up for the blog. This site ended up being a wonderful compilation of our year come June. I still use it as a preview site for students, parents, and pre-service teachers I work with, as to what we do during the year. The blog can be viewed at http://shmshistoryclass.blogspot.com/.

That same year, an after-school group that is co-sponsored by myself and a friend from the National Park Service took a cross-country trip for Lincoln’s Bicentennial. I created another blog for the students to document their adventures and for friends and family back home to be able to find us. What was nice was that because I had been working with the blog in history class, my students were aware of how a blog works and were familiar with how to write for it and their audience. Each student was required to write three times for the blog during the course of our week-long adventure. Each night after our full day they would write on either paper or share the two laptops we brought for blogging. Before going to bed each night I would upload any remaining blog entries. The system proved effective for sharing our adventures and for students documenting their days. The site has also become a great way for Jen Epstein, my National Park Service co-organizer, to share what she is doing in schools for outreach. View it here: http://stampslincoln.blogspot.com/.

Blogging Expanded

With two school group blogs under my belt, I decided to ramp it up for the 2009–2010 school year. I wanted students to be able to learn how to blog . . . not just post, but learn the process. I set out the planning of it before school started. Basically, I decided to have students choose their groupmates in the class they were in. I have approximately 100 students each year and about 25 per history class. I asked them to be in groups of three or four students.

I wanted students to be able to learn how to blog . . . not just post, but learn the process.

Once they chose their groups (and we discussed the characteristics of a quality groupmate, both in a group partner and as a group partner—they are 8th grade after all!), I gave them a sheet that asked them to record their group member names, create a name for their blog, and to write a username and a password that they would remember (not one that was already in use by one of the group members!). I created Google accounts for each student using the information provided, noting on their sheet, if a username was taken, the reassigned username.

Generally, I’ve found that it takes about a week for me to set up the 30 or so email accounts and blog sites. I introduce the blog and what it will be about, how it will be used, etc., and then come back to it about a week later once I’ve created the accounts and site. We spend a full double block learning to log in, changing the appearance of the blog, and learning to post. We generally do the first blog post together. We discuss the elements of a quality blog post—what am I looking for? Points I stress are that it is still for class—correct English grammar must be used. For all intents and purposes, I am their audience (so it should remain as formal writing), and the blog is only for history class. I do not want to read about their weekend experiences on this blog.

Usually, after a guest speaker they have a blog update to do. Sometimes they turn in an assignment and then I ask them to cut and paste what they have typed and to post it. Other times I have them work as a group to post a response to something in class.

Points to Consider

I find that they’re pretty excited about the blogs and they like to write on them. I’ve learned that a clear rubric is key to success—for the students but for my grading as well. Just as any teacher would do for a writing assignment, it is important to lay out the criteria for the post in advance. Am I grading on content? Spelling? Grammar? Reflection? When grading 30 blogs, it becomes ultra important to be able to know what I’m looking for, especially because their posts can vary so much.

I find that it is important to be very clear with parents about expectations as well.

Another important note to consider is deadlines. Because students aren’t turning in a physical paper, it’s easy for them to forget deadlines and to overlook them. I find that it’s important to have a final cut-off date for grading blogs . . . along with a lot of reminders. Many parents are not familiar with blogging and so I find that it is important to be very clear with parents about expectations as well. Last year I ran a parent workshop and walked parents through the what, how, and why of blogging so that they could better support their children at home . . . and because I was getting a lot of questions!

I’m fortunate enough to have a classroom set of laptops and a relatively new and working internet system. However, the number of computers is what has dictated my choices for class blog site vs. small group blog sites. When I started in 2008, I had only two laptops and a desktop, with no permanent and/or regular access to a classroom set of computers.

My recommendation would be to start small—either with a classroom blog or with a select group of students. Simultaneously, I was blogging on a personal blog and it helped for me to play around with my own blog. I found the Google help site for Blogger very helpful when teaching my students. Pages can be printed and copied for students and then put in their notebooks to be referenced. (Editor's note: If you're using a different blogging service, look for that service's support documentation.)

The Advantages of Blogging

For me, blogs are really flexible—for both time and content. While I’ve used them for the duration of a school year, they would be great for a unit project or a semester project. And for those students who are really savvy, it’s a great way to engage them by having them add other multimedia objects to their blogs and to embed links to related content material.

Just remember to give yourself a head start and don’t be afraid to play around!

The ideas truly are endless! The winter break and other school breaks really lend themselves to my own exploration time on the blog. It allows me to see what I could implement with my students and to think about how it might further benefit what I am teaching in the classroom. Just remember to give yourself a head start and don’t be afraid to play around! Blogging can be wonderful for both you and the students!

For more information

Curious to learn more about blogs and blogging? Our Tech for Teachers entry on blogs looks at some possible platforms, and, in a Teaching Guide, high-school teacher Kyle Smith details one way of using a blog in class.

Read other ideas from Amy Trenkle in her blog entries on teaching Christopher Columbus with monuments and celebrating the First Amendment.