Using Historical Footage (Elementary)
How do we know Venture Smith’s story?
How do we know Venture Smith’s story?
History is complicated and in our attempts to simplify it for young children we often change it, sometimes drastically. The story of Christopher Columbus is one example. For generations we have passed down myths about this man. We have taught children that he alone believed the world was round, when, in truth, many if not most people of his time understood that the world is round. We have taught that he discovered a new world. How could he discover it if people were already living there? We have also taught that he died not realizing what he had 'discovered.'
Elementary school teachers have a unique challenge: they teach all subjects rather than focus on one. Not surprisingly, it is difficult to be experts in everything.
One way to address this challenge is to allow students to recognize the questions. We don't have to have all the answers. In fact, when it comes to history it is not possible to know all the answers. Historians continue to study a wide range of primary sources and to disagree with previous assertions and with each other. It is important that students be allowed to wrestle with this uncertainty rather than to blindly accept what we state as fact. Even the youngest children can understand that adults are still learning, and can enjoy learning along with us.
If you are interested in tackling the complexities of Christopher Columbus, there are some great places to start. James Loewen's book, Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your American History Textbook Got Wrong, is a good one and helpful for subjects far beyond Columbus. The Library of Congress has an exhibit entitled 1492: An Ongoing Voyage that includes interesting information on Columbus's coat of arms. An examination and discussion of his coat of arms can encompass quite a bit of information about the man and his achievements. The Gilder Lehrman Institute of American History's June 2007 History Now includes an article detailing the benefits and difficulties faced by both Columbus and his men and those people already living in the New World. If you are interested in the geography of Columbus's journeys or his logs, one individual has created a site which includes maps and information about the logs, navigation, the ships, and the crew.
One thing children can understand about Columbus and what he achieved was that he did so by "standing on the shoulders of giants" (a phrase from Isaac Newton). Columbus learned from those who came before him, about navigation, geography, and other cultures. Learning from others and building on that knowledge are strategies we should be helping our students develop. That is a worthy lesson to take from Columbus.
Try our quiz on Christoper Columbus's portraits!
The Ad Council has been producing public service announcements attempting to affect change in society and serve the public interest for nearly 70 years. The campaigns take the form of print, radio, and television advertisements. They have run the spectrum of societal issues, from "Rosie the Riveter" and the campaign to place women in war jobs to contemporary ads related to predatory lending. The Ad Council has brought us memorable characters like Smokey Bear, McGruff the Crime Dog, and Vince and Larry (the two crash test dummies who convinced us to wear seat belts). But what do these public advertising campaigns say about America? How can we use these ad campaigns to better understand U.S. history?
Through analyzing the ads we can isolate time periods in history and understand what were believed to be the most pressing societal issues of the time. These campaigns tried to decrease behaviors that were believed to lead to social problems or promote behaviors that would lead to a better society. Thus, in seeking to understand the advertisements, we can help students uncover the contemporaneous sociology of the ad campaign.
You can begin by exploring the Ad Council's Historic Campaigns that highlight some of the more notable campaigns in the last 70 years. Each campaign is complete with background information and some have links to PSA videos associated with the campaign. An even more complete retrospective of past advertising campaigns is maintained by the Advertising Educational Foundation and can be accessed here.
I have found the site particularly useful in helping students understand more recent history. For instance, few would disagree that, socially, the 1980s were rocked by the AIDS epidemic. The site highlights PSAs to prevent the spread of AIDS, which represent a dramatic shift in societal norms with the public call for condom use. The ads on crime prevention featuring McGruff the Crime Dog also help illuminate the 1980s. These ads coincide with America's "war on drugs" and emphasis on law and order during the 1980s. 1970s culture was epitomized by environmental awareness featuring Ad Council PSAs showing Native Americans distraught to find their territory littered. These ads and more can be found in the Historic Campaigns section.
Teaching with advertisements as primary sources is beneficial in two ways. One, students are exposed to yet another example of primary sources that come with their own unique set of historical questions. Two, by learning how to unpack the intent of advertisements on people of the past, students are more apt to be able to recognize advertising manipulation in the present. The Ad Council dedicates a page of resources for educators that includes useful links and frequently asked questions. These pages also identify current advertising campaigns, which might be useful for students to identify some of the important topics of today compared to the important issues they find in earlier decades.
Before having students analyze advertisements as primary sources, it is important to model for students how advertisements should be read. Students should also be made aware of the strengths and limitations of using advertisements to understand the past. An excellent overview of these strengths and weaknesses can be found on page 11 of this guide to primary sources, from the Smithsonian's History Explorer, along with questions to guide students in analyzing advertisements.
A natural fit to teaching U.S. history through public service announcements would be to have students create their own PSAs. Students could be given a list of pertinent social issues to a particular time period or could be asked to research important topics on their own. Students could write a script and use a pocket camcorder to record their PSA. Editing could be done using iMovie, Windows MovieMaker, or any number of free online video editing tools. The purpose of the assignment is to help students understand the changing nature of social issues in the United States.
Another idea is to have students research the effectiveness of given historic campaigns. The Ad Council maintains a database of reports and figures related to the success of various PSAs. This is a condensed version highlighting the impact of the Ad Council's more famous campaigns. The purpose here is to help students see how effective advertising not only convinces people to buy products, but also can convince people to change behavior for the common good.
The Ad Council works to address the most significant social issues of the day. With that purpose, the Ad Council offers a unique look into making sense of our social past by revealing important issues of the time. Advertisements offer students an opportunity to interpret an overlooked type of primary source of the past and establish connections to the present.
Looking for more guidelines on using ads in the classroom? Historian Daniel Pope helps you make sense of advertisements, and historian Roger Horowitz analyzes historical documents behind 1950s potato chip advertising campaigns. This syllabus from a university history course also walks you through the steps of analyzing an ad.
Search our Website Reviews using the keyword "advertisement" for reviews of more than 200 websites featuring archived advertisements.
(Note: By the completion of second grade, Iowa students are expected to master the following standards.)
Behavioral sciences include, but are not limited to, the areas of sociology, anthropology and psychology. In addressing these disciplines the actions and reactions of humans are studied through observational and experimental methods.
Understand the changing nature of society.
Understand all people have individual traits.
Understand interactions between self and the peer group.
Understand the relationship of the individual to the components of society and culture.
Economics addresses the production, distribution, and consumption of goods and services. The concept of scarcity is understood to mean that available resources are insufficient to satisfy the wants and needs of everyone. Economics is therefore founded upon the alternative use of available resources and the study of choices.
Understand the role of scarcity and economic trade-offs and how economic conditions impact people’s lives.
Understand that the basic nature of economics is an exchange of resources.
Understand how governments throughout the world influence economic behavior.
Understand people in all parts of the world trade with one another.
Understand that changes in technology impact individuals, the economy and society.
Understand the universal economic concept of needs and wants.
Geography is the study of the interaction between people and their environments. Geography therefore looks at the world through the concepts of location, place, human-environmental interaction, movement, and region.
Understand the use of geographic tools to locate and analyze information about people, places, and environments.
Understand how geographic and human characteristics create culture and define regions.
Understand how human factors and the distribution of resources affect the development of communities and the movement of populations.
Understand how geographic processes and human actions modify the environment and how the environment affects humans.
History is the study and analysis of the past. Built upon a foundation of historical knowledge, history seeks to analyze the past in order to describe the relationship between historical facts, concepts, and generalizations. History draws upon cause and effect relationships within multiple social narratives to help explain complex human interactions. Understanding the past provides context for the present and implications for the future.
Understand people construct knowledge of the past from multiple and various types of sources.
Understand how and why people create and participate in governance.
Understand culture and how cultural diffusion affects the development and maintenance of societies.
Understand individuals and groups within a society may promote change or the status quo.
Understand economic needs and wants affect individual and group decisions.
Understand relationship between geography and historical events.
Understand cause and effect relationships and other historical thinking skills in order to interpret events and issues.
Political science is the study of power and authority through the examination of political processes, governmental institutions, and human behavior in a civil society. In this context the study of civics is understood to include the form and function of government. Civic literacy encompasses civics but also addresses the individual’s social and political participation.
Understand the basic concepts of government and democracy and that the Constitution defines the rights and responsibilities of citizens.
Understand how government affects citizens and how citizens affect government.
Understand the United States has a role in current world affairs.
The student will recognize that history describes events and people of other times and places by
The student will describe everyday life in the present and in the past and begin to recognize that things change over time.
The student will describe the relative location of people, places, and things by using positional words, with emphasis on near/far, above/below, left/right, and behind/in front.
The student will use simple maps and globes to
The student will develop an awareness that maps and globes
The student will match simple descriptions of work that people do with the names of those jobs.
The student will
The student will demonstrate that being a good citizen involves
The student will recognize the American flag, the Pledge of Allegiance, and that the President is the leader of the United States.
Students demonstrate how structures of power, authority, and governance have developed historically and continue to evolve.
Students describe and apply rights and responsibilities of citizenship.
Students explain how rules and laws affect families, schools, communities, and states.
Students demonstrate an understanding of different cultures and how these cultures have contributed and continue to contribute to the world in which they live.
Students describe how human needs and concerns (i.e. freedom, justice, and responsibility) are addressed within cultures.
Students explain how culture is reflected in literature and the arts.
Students demonstrate an understanding of economic principles and concepts and describe the influence of economic factors on societies.
Students describe the importance of major resources, industries, and economic development of the local community and Wyoming.
Students describe different ways that people earn a living in the local community and in Wyoming.
Students demonstrate an understanding of the people, events, problems, ideas, and cultures that were significant in the history of our community, state, nation and world.
Students identify significant local, state and national persons, holidays, and symbols.
Students discuss and describe how current events influence individuals, communities, state, country, and/or world.
Students describe the chronology of exploration, immigration and settlement of Wyoming.
Students demonstrate an understanding of interrelationships among people, places, and environments.
Students use physical maps, political maps, and globes to identify locations using scale, cardinal and intermediate directions, legends, keys, and symbols.
Students identify their relative location in terms of home, school, neighborhood, community, county, state, country, and continent.
Students locate major landmarks, landforms, and areas/regions in the community and in Wyoming.
Students describe relationships among people and places, and the environmental context in which they take place.
People, Places and Environments: Students in Wisconsin will learn about geography through the study of the relationships among people, places, and environments.
Use reference points, latitude and longitude, direction, size, shape, and scale to locate positions on various representations of the earth's surface.
Locate on a map or globe physical features such as continents, oceans, mountain ranges, and land forms, natural features such as resources, flora, and fauna; and human features such as cities, states, and national borders.
Construct a map of the world from memory, showing the location of major land masses, bodies of water, and mountain ranges.
Describe and give examples of ways in which people interact with the physical environment, including use of land, location of communities, methods of construction, and design of shelters.
Use atlases, databases, grid systems, charts, graphs, and maps to gather information about the local community, Wisconsin, the United States, and the world.
Identify and distinguish between predictable environmental changes, such as weather patterns and seasons, and unpredictable changes, such as floods and droughts, and describe the social and economic effects of these changes.
Identify connections between the local community and other places in Wisconsin, the United States, and the world.
Identify major changes in the local community that have been caused by human beings, such as a construction project, a new highway, a building torn down, or a fire; discuss reasons for these changes; and explain their probable effects on the community and the environment.
Give examples to show how scientific and technological knowledge has led to environmental changes, such as pollution prevention measures, air-conditioning, and solar heating.
Time, Continuity, and Change: Students in Wisconsin will learn about the history of Wisconsin, the United States, and the world, examining change and continuity over time in order to develop historical perspective, explain historical relationships, and analyze issues that affect the present and the future.
Identify and examine various sources of information that are used for constructing an understanding of the past, such as artifacts, documents, letters, diaries, maps, textbooks, photos, paintings, architecture, oral presentations, graphs, and charts.
Use a timeline to select, organize, and sequence information describing eras in history.
Examine biographies, stories, narratives, and folk tales to understand the lives of ordinary and extraordinary people, place them in time and context, and explain their relationship to important historical events.
Compare and contrast changes in contemporary life with life in the past by looking at social, economic, political, and cultural roles played by individuals and groups.
Identify the historical background and meaning of important political values such as freedom, democracy, and justice.
Explain the significance of national and state holidays, such as Independence Day and Martin Luther King, Jr. Day, and national and state symbols, such as the United States flag and the state flags.
Identify and describe important events and famous people in Wisconsin and United States history.
Compare past and present technologies related to energy, transportation, and communications and describe the effects of technological change, either beneficial or harmful, on people and the environment.
Describe examples of cooperation and interdependence among individuals, groups, and nations.
Explain the history, culture, tribal sovereignty, and current status of the American Indian tribes and bands in Wisconsin.
Power, Authority, Governance, and Responsibility: Students in Wisconsin will learn about political science and acquire the knowledge of political systems necessary for developing individual civic responsibility by studying the history and contemporary uses of power, authority, and governance.
Identify and explain the individual's responsibilities to family, peers, and the community, including the need for civility and respect for diversity.
Identify the documents, such as the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and the Bill of Rights, in which the rights of citizens in our country are guaranteed.
Explain how families, schools, and other groups develop, enforce, and change rules of behavior and explain how various behaviors promote or hinder cooperation.
Explain the basic purpose of government in American society, recognizing the three levels of government.
Explain how various forms of civic action such as running for political office, voting, signing an initiative, and speaking at hearings, can contribute to the well-being of the community.
Locate, organize, and use relevant information to understand an issue in the classroom or school, while taking into account the viewpoints and interests of different groups and individuals.
Production, Distribution, Exchange, Consumption: Students in Wisconsin will learn about production, distribution, exchange, and consumption so that they can make informed economic decisions.
Describe and explain of the role of money, banking, and savings in everyday life.
Identify situations requiring an allocation of limited economic resources and appraise the opportunity cost (for example, spending one's allowance on a movie will mean less money saved for a new video game).
Identify local goods and services that are part of the global economy and explain their use in Wisconsin.
Give examples to explain how businesses and industry depend upon workers with specialized skills to make production more efficient.
Distinguish between private goods and services (for example, the family car or a local restaurant) and public goods and services (for example, the interstate highway system or the United States Postal Service).
Identify the economic roles of various institutions, including households, businesses, and government.
Describe how personal economic decisions, such as deciding what to buy, what to recycle, or how much to contribute to people in need, can affect the lives of people in Wisconsin, the United States, and the world.
Individuals, Institutions, and Society: Students in Wisconsin will learn about the behavioral sciences by exploring concepts from the discipline of sociology, the study of the interactions among individuals, groups, and institutions; the discipline of psychology, the study of factors that influence individual identity and learning; and the discipline of anthropology, the study of cultures in various times and settings.
Explain the influence of prior knowledge, motivation, capabilities, personal interests, and other factors on individual learning.
Explain the influence of factors such as family, neighborhood, personal interests, language, likes and dislikes, and accomplishments on individual identity and development.
Describe how families are alike and different, comparing characteristics such as size, hobbies, celebrations, where families live, and how they make a living.
Describe the ways in which ethnic cultures influence the daily lives of people.
Identify and describe institutions such as school, church, police, and family and describe their contributions to the well being of the community, state, nation, and global society.
Give examples of group and institutional influences such as laws, rules, and peer pressure on people, events, and culture.
Explain the reasons why individuals respond in different ways to a particular event and the ways in which interactions among individuals influence behavior.
Describe and distinguish among the values and beliefs of different groups and institutions.
Explain how people learn about others who are different from themselves.
Give examples and explain how the media may influence opinions, choices, and decisions.
Give examples and explain how language, stories, folk tales, music, and other artistic creations are expressions of culture and how they convey knowledge of other peoples and cultures.
Give examples of important contributions made by Wisconsin citizens, United States citizens, and world citizens.
Investigate and explain similarities and differences in ways that cultures meet human needs.
Describe how differences in cultures may lead to understanding or misunderstanding among people.
Describe instances of cooperation and interdependence among individuals, groups, and nations, such as helping others in famines and disasters.
The student understands and applies knowledge of government, law, politics, and the nation's fundamental documents to make decisions about local, national, and international issues and to demonstrate thoughtful, participatory citizenship.
Understands key ideals and principles of the United States, including those in the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and other fundamental documents.
Understands the purposes, organization, and function of governments, laws, and political systems.
Remembers the people who make and carry out rules in the classroom and school.
Understands the purpose of rules in the classroom and school.
The student understands and applies knowledge of historical thinking, chronology, eras, turning points, major ideas, individuals, and themes in local, Washington State, tribal, United States, and world history in order to evaluate how history shapes the present and future.
Understands historical chronology.
Understands and creates timelines to show personal events in a sequential manner.
The student understands and applies reasoning skills to conduct research, deliberate, form, and evaluate positions through the processes of reading, writing, and communicating.
Uses critical reasoning skills to analyze and evaluate positions.
Understands one's point of view.
Evaluates the fairness of one's point of view.
Uses inquiry-based research.
Understands how to ask questions about the classroom and school community.
Deliberates public issues.
States own viewpoints and listens to viewpoints of others.
Creates a product that uses social studies content to support a thesis and presents the product in an appropriate manner to a meaningful audience.
Retells and explains personal history.
Culture encompasses similarities and differences among people, including their beliefs, knowledge, changes, values, and traditions. Students will explore these elements of society to develop an appreciation and respect for the variety of human cultures.
Understand the diversity of human cultures.
Identify personal attributes, such as physical characteristics, that are common to all people such as physical characteristics.
Identify differences among people.
Recognize how individuals learn to do skills and customs from their culture.
Recognize all cultures have family units where decisions are made.
Discuss cultures and human patterns of places and regions of the world. Understand that some differences among people are a result of their culture.
Identify similarities and differences in food, clothes, homes, games, and families in different cultures.
Explain how means of transportation may be diversified in different cultures in response to the environment.
Compare family customs and traditions among cultures.
Describe customs of the local community.
Recognize the contributions that individuals and people of various ethnic, racial, religious, and socioeconomic groups have made to the development of civilizations.
Recognize contributions of different cultures around the world.
Explain the value of family traditions and customs.
Globalization of the economy, the explosion of population growth, technological changes and international competition compel students to understand, both personally and globally, the production, distribution, and consumption of goods and services. Students will examine and analyze economic concepts such as basic needs versus wants, using versus/saving money, and policy making versus decision making.
Describe potential costs and benefits of personal economic choices in a market economy.
Identify basic human needs.
Explain how basic human needs of food, clothing, shelter, and transportation are met.
Understand that people create shelter according to both culture and environment.
Give examples of the interaction of businesses and governments in a market economy.
Recognize how jobs are similar and different from one community to another.
Identify jobs in the home, and school.
Understand fundamental economic concepts.
Explain why people have jobs.
Distinguish between needs and wants.
Recognize that all jobs are significant and realize that some jobs are interdependent.
Geography enables the students to see, understand and appreciate the web of relationships between people, places, and environments. Students will use the knowledge, skills, and understanding of concepts within the six essential elements of geography: world in spatial terms, places and regions, physical systems, human systems, environment and society, and the uses of geography.
Understand how to use maps, globes, and other geographic representations, tools, and technologies to acquire, process and report information from a spatial perspective.
Explain what a globe and map represent.
Use personal directions such as up, down, left, right, near and far to describe relative direction.
Locate places in community such as the student's home and the classroom on the campus.
Recognize the interaction between human and physical systems around the world.
Identify the human characteristics of places such as types of houses and ways of earning a living.
Describe how weather impacts every daily life.
Describe seasons.
Demonstrate how to identify and locate major physical and political features on globes and maps.
Identify the concept of physical features as in mountains, plains, hills, oceans, and islands.
Describe how landforms and bodies of water influence where and how people live.
Describe personal connections to place, especially place as associated with immediate surroundings.
Governance establishes structures of power and authority in order to provide order and stability. Civic efficacy requires understanding rights and responsibilities, ethical behavior, and the role of citizens within their community, nation, and world.
Discuss the structure and purposes of governance.
Recognize that a person is a citizen of the country in which he/she is born.
Understand that rules are created to protect an environment.
Know that family structures can change.
Identify authority figures in the home, school, and community.
Explain how authority figures make and enforce rules.
Explain the use of voting as a method for group decision-making.
Describe the Constitution of the United States and the Tennessee State Constitution in principle and practice.
Recognize the need for rules for daily living and fair treatment of others.
Identify purposes for having rules.
Be aware that laws and rules are followed and created by the people, school, community, and country.
Understand the rights, responsibilities, and privileges of citizens living in a democratic republic.
Know rules of safety including signs and signals.
Define cooperation.
Recognize the qualities of a contributing citizen in our participatory democracy.
Identify the flags of the United States and Tennessee.
Recite the Pledge of Allegiance.
Explain the reasons for national patriotic holidays such as President's Day, Martin Luther King, Jr. Day, and Independence Day.
History involves people, events, and issues. Students will evaluate evidence to develop comparative and casual analyses, and to interpret primary sources. They will construct sound historical arguments and perspectives on which informed decisions in contemporary life can be based.
Identify major events, people, and patterns Tennessee, United States, and world history.
Define history as the story of our past.
Recall events in the past and present in order to recognize that individuals have a personal history.
Illustrate a family history to demonstrate that every family has a heritage.
Understand the place of historical events in the context of past, present, and future.
Recognize that change occurs over time.
Observe how sites in neighborhoods and communities change over time.
Explain how to use historical information acquired from a variety of sources.
Recognize that each family has a family tree.
Recall family stories and celebrations to develop a personal history.
Personal development and identity are shaped by factors including culture, groups, and institutions. Central to this development are exploration, identification, and analysis of how individuals, and groups work independently and cooperatively.
Recognize the impact of individual and group decisions on citizens and communities.
Describe how individuals meet their needs and wants through different means.
Know that individuals choose jobs that impact their lives, families and communities.
Explain that people learn in the context of families, peers, schools, and communities.
Give examples of how learning and physical development affect behavior.
Explain the consequences of an individual's decisions and actions.
Understand how groups can impact change at the local, state, national, and world levels.
Recognize individuals have a space or develop an understanding of space and spatial relationships.
Understand that cooperation is necessary when working within large and small groups to complete tasks.
Work independently and cooperatively to accomplish goals.
Describe how groups are made up of people who work, play, or learn together and share common interests.
Students will understand the emergence and development of civilizations and cultures within the United States over time and place.
Analyze U.S. historical eras to determine connections and cause/effect relationships in reference to chronology.
Mastery of this indicator does not emerge until first grade.
Evaluate the influence/impact of various cultures, values, philosophies, and religions on the development of the U.S.
Mastery of this indicator does not emerge until first grade.
Students will understand the emergence and development of world civilizations and cultures over time and place.
Analyze historical eras of world history to determine connections and cause/effect relationships in reference to chronology.
Mastery of this indicator does not emerge until third grade.
Evaluate the interaction of world cultures and civilizations, philosophies, and religions.
Mastery of this indicator does not emerge until second grade.
Students will understand the interrelationships of people, places, and the environment.
Analyze information from geographic representation, tools, and technology to define location, place, and region.
(Application) Students are able to use map colors to recognize land and water.
(Comprehension) Students are able to compare the globe and a map as models of the Earth.
(Application) Students are able to demonstrate familiarity with the layout of their own school.
Students will understand the historical development and contemporary role of governmental power and authority.
Analyze forms and purposes of government in relationship to the needs of citizens and societies including the impact of historical events, ideals, and documents.
Mastery of this indicator does not emerge until first grade.
Analyze the constitutional rights and responsibilities of United States citizens.
Mastery of this indicator does not emerge until first grade.
Students will understand the impact of economics on the development of societies and on current and emerging national and international situations.
Analyze the role and relationships of economic systems on the development, utilization, and availability of resources in societies.
(Knowledge) Students are able to identify occupations with simple descriptions of work.
(Knowledge) Students are able to identify the difference between basic needs (food, clothing, and shelter) and wants (luxuries).
(Comprehension) Students are able to describe the role of money in everyday life.